Every Jewish Voice Matters – In Israel and abroad

As Rabbi Jonathan Sacks so eloquently put it, “Judaism is not a religion of uniformity but of unity in diversity. We are one people with many voices, each contributing to the symphony of the Jewish soul.” This unity inspires us to challenge the notion that some Jewish voices matter less.

Over the past few months, I’ve come across several opinion pieces suggesting that being in the Diaspora is somehow “less than.” That Jews living outside Israel have less right to speak, to feel, or to be heard. I believe this is fundamentally incorrect.

The truth is, I once held this view myself—both when I lived in the UK and even after moving to Israel. But over time, and through reflection, I’ve come to see things differently. The tragic murder of Yaron Lischinsky and Sarah Milgrim didn’t form my opinion, but it starkly illustrated it: every Jewish voice matters—and we all take risks.

As we celebrate Shavuot, which commemorates the Giving of the Torah to Jews— notably outside the Land of Israel, and arguably on the very day that those outside Israel are celebrating the second day of the Chag—we must frame our joint mission as one people and avoid senseless disunity.

The Reality of Jewish Life in the Diaspora

Living openly as a Jew abroad presents unique challenges. In Israel, I was privileged to go to work (well before my retirement, anyway) surrounded by people who share my belief in Israel’s right to exist. Even non-Jews here often self-select to engage with Israeli society. Abroad, revealing one’s Jewish identity can invite conscious or subconscious hostility—a fear Israelis rarely experience.

A recent incident abroad crystallized this for me. On a tour bus in a friendly country, the guide listed everyone’s origins—Germany, India, USA, Australia, UK—but omitted “Israel” next to my name, despite it being clearly written on the list he held. When I asked why, he avoided answering. I have my suspicions.

Such microaggressions—and far more dangerous threats—are a constant burden for Jews abroad. Just last week, two young people—one Jewish, one Christian—were senselessly murdered while attending a meeting at the Jewish Museum in Washington, D.C. Even small acts, like mentioning you’re from Israel when booking an Airbnb, can feel like calculated risks. It is a daily reality of life abroad.

Diaspora Jews: Advocates and Bridges

Despite these challenges, Diaspora Jews play a vital role. They defend Israel’s position, act as cultural bridges, and support Israel in countless ways. Though often outnumbered in public discourse, their efforts are invaluable—even when defending policies they didn’t shape or a government they can’t vote for.

They are often blamed for dual allegiance, when in fact they usually act as the most loyal of citizens—albeit with an additional call on their heart (something shared by the vast majority of families who have, at any time, recently migrated between countries).

The contributions of Jews in Israel, especially those on the front lines, are undeniable. But this doesn’t diminish the value of Diaspora advocacy. Measuring impact is complex—and not for us to judge. Every Jew who stands up, speaks out, and supports our people is part of the same mission.

For the first time in thousands of years, Jews have a homeland within easy reach. It is open to all and a truly wondrous nation—despite its very clear challenges and areas of improvement. That so many have migrated is a miracle. It still, however, benefits from a strong and vibrant Diaspora community, and that symbiosis is important.

Not a Halachic Argument

Let me be clear: I’m not making a halachic argument, nor am I denying the religious significance of making Aliyah. It is critical. But I do recognize that many Jews remain abroad for valid reasons. For some, the barriers—economic, cultural, social, or educational—are simply too great.

Many feel a deep desire to live in Israel but are, in a sense, “trapped” abroad. Their pain is real. Their connection to Israel often manifests through their children, who have disproportionately served in recent conflicts. Their love for Israel is no less profound for being lived at a distance.

Life in Israel: Challenges and Privileges

Living in Israel is both a privilege and a challenge. Those of us with children, partners, or siblings serving in the IDF understand this deeply, as do those who have suffered from terrorism. Many make immense sacrifices—economically, socially, and emotionally—to live here.

Personally, I’ve found life in Israel vivid, exciting, and deeply rewarding. Still, I’ll admit—somewhat lightheartedly—that my first Israeli salary was just 27% of my London one. That small anecdote hints at the broader reality: living here isn’t always easy. But for many of us, it’s worth it.

The Freedom to Speak

One of the privileges of living in Israel is the freedom to express myself. I’ve written extensively about Israel over the past few years—a freedom I likely wouldn’t have abroad. My children have benefited immensely from life here and have been willing to sacrifice for it.

That freedom comes with responsibility—to listen, to include, and to value every Jewish voice.

A Unified Jewish Mission

As Elie Wiesel profoundly stated, “Wherever we are, we carry the weight and the hope of our people. To be a Jew is to be an ambassador of memory and morality.”

The role of the Jew extends beyond defending Israel’s right to exist. It’s part of a broader mission to bring light and energy to the world. The roles of Israeli and Diaspora Jews are distinct—but equally essential.

Over millennia, Jews have positively influenced the societies they’ve touched. Life isn’t binary—it’s complex. G-d has created a world where Jews, and their supporters, play diverse roles in different places.

I hope every Jew can contribute to strengthening our people and building a better world. The more we support each other, the stronger we all become.