Faith, Fear and the Burden of Identity
The big issue that Christians and Jews clash on is obviously number one: Jesus, but then there are the derivative ramifications. Things like whether the Torah commandments are binding, the focus of life, end times (eschatology is the fancy word for that) and the afterlife. Leafing through the New Testament, Jesus is transformed from the baby wrapped in swaddling clothes of the Gospels to a terrifying depiction of eyes like blazing fire in Revelation. The Messiah has to accomplish a lot. The Jewish version is really taking His time to get started, and the Christian version is taking His time to finish the job.
Accompanying the more conservative wings of both Judaism and Christianity is a sense of urgent stress. The evangelical is meant to believe that all those who fail to place their faith in the atoning sacrifice of Jesus for their sins will one day be cast into the eternal lake of fire. Some are better suited than others to stomach the gravity of this reality, whether that be due to resolute conviction or an abnormality of the mind. Orthodox Judaism taxes a different kind of psychological toll by exacting in the degree of piety demanded to make good.
On the liberal end you need a fair bit of dosh to fit in as a Jew, especially in golus (the diaspora). You can get away with a meager living in most streams of Christianity, but the Americans believe in pursuing prosperity (otherwise they wouldn’t be Americans).
A dimension that uniquely touches and concerns Jewish experience is the notion of ethnicity and nationhood beyond the regularities of religion. This can cause an enormous degree of sorrow and confusion. The Holocaust was perpetrated against the Jewish people within living memory, yet now the world has the chutzpah to accuse the Jewish State that emerged out of the embers of the destruction of European Jewry of inflicting the same atrocity. That can really mess with one’s mind. Another aspect of insular ethnicity that causes untold floods of grief is the expectational pressure to not marry out. There’s a big world out there full of wonderful shiksas and goyim. Laying one’s heart on the altar of Jewish continuity is an agonising calculation for many. Certain parallels can be found with evangelical Christians and conservative Catholics feeling pressure to find a spouse who embraces their faith, but in such situations there is a much larger pool of eligible candidates.
Bringing it back to the original point concerning Jesus – it seems surprising that he was categorically rejected by Judaism. His teachings are more or less congruent with the thrust of contemporary Rabbinic teachings that were later recorded in the Mishnah. Moreover, Jesus is our Star performer. No other Jew has had as great an influence and been so adored by the Goyim. So why not extend Him some much due courtesy and respect. Aren’t Jews known for their PR?
Related Topics
