Jeffrey Levine
CFO | Empower Society for Good I Author

How Do You Stay Honest in a World of Lies?

Why does life have to be so complicated?

We live in an age of extraordinary information, yet increasingly we seem unable to distinguish truth from falsehood.

Everyone has a narrative. Everyone has somebody to blame. We reduce complex realities to convenient labels: victim or aggressor, good or evil, oppressor or oppressed.

Once the label is applied, the discussion often ends.

But is that how we discover truth?

This week’s parsha, Vayetze, offers a fascinating perspective through the story of Jacob and Laban.

When the deceiver becomes the deceived

Jacob leaves Beersheba for Haran, where he will establish the family that becomes the Jewish people.

But Jacob is no stranger to deception.

He has already impersonated Esau to obtain the blessing from his blind father Isaac.

Rabbi Shai Held raises an uncomfortable question. When Rebecca proposes the deception, Jacob’s concern is not primarily whether it is wrong. He worries about being discovered and cursed.

He appears more concerned about getting caught than about the deception itself.

Then Jacob meets Laban.

He works seven years to marry Rachel, only to discover that Laban has substituted Leah.

“Why did you deceive me?” Jacob demands (Genesis 29:25).

Laban replies:

“It is not done in our place to give the younger before the firstborn” (Genesis 29:26).

The younger before the older!

Exactly what Jacob had done to Esau.

Rabbi Held describes this as middah keneged middah — measure for measure.

Jacob experiences the very behaviour he previously inflicted upon others.

The Torah does not present its heroes as flawless. Even Jacob must confront his conduct.

We cannot demand honesty from others while excusing dishonesty in ourselves.

When deception becomes your reality

A second commentary, from Echoes of Rashi, by Rabbi Moshe Taragin, offers another remarkable insight.

When Jacob and Laban negotiate his wages, Jacob carefully defines which spotted and speckled animals will belong to him.

The terms are precise, transparent and verifiable.

Yet Laban remains suspicious.

The commentary suggests that Laban has become so accustomed to deception that he cannot imagine Jacob genuinely intends to honour their agreement.

He assumes everybody operates as he does.

And that is the tragedy.

When dishonesty becomes habitual, we begin to assume everybody else is dishonest too.

We stop examining evidence and start attributing motives.

We stop listening and start labelling.

Eventually, the label becomes more important than reality.

Lewis Hamilton, Richard Kemp and the blame game

Two contrasting perspectives brought this home to me.

Formula One champion Lewis Hamilton recently visited the Egyptian side of the Rafah crossing, where he observed humanitarian supplies intended for Gaza.

He subsequently accused Israel of genocide and demanded humanitarian access.

I do not question his compassion for suffering Palestinian children. Their suffering is real and demands action.

But I was troubled by the certainty with which an extraordinarily complicated conflict was reduced to one sweeping accusation.

Hamilton was standing in Egypt.

Did he ask why Egypt has resisted offering broader temporary refuge to Palestinian civilians?

Could other Arab countries help accommodate families voluntarily seeking safety?

What responsibility does Hamas bear for the war and its consequences?

And what about Israel’s obligation to protect its citizens against further attacks?

None of these questions eliminates Israel’s responsibilities, including its obligations concerning humanitarian aid.

But surely they form part of the reality.

I reject the characterisation of Israel’s war as genocide, while recognising that international investigators have reached differing conclusions. An allegation of this gravity demands rigorous examination, not merely repetition.

Now consider Colonel Richard Kemp, the former commander of British forces in Afghanistan.

Kemp has repeatedly emphasised the strategic importance of the high ground in Judea and Samaria.

His approach begins with military realities.

What happens if strategically important hills overlooking Israeli population centres fall under the control of hostile armed groups?

What would that mean for nearby communities, transport routes and infrastructure?

His argument is that these are concrete security risks, not abstract political concerns.

Security considerations do not automatically resolve questions concerning settlements or Jewish and Palestinian rights.

Today, we need an approach that examines practical consequences and takes into account the facts on the ground. We, i.e., the Government of Israel, need to set the agenda instead of waiting for others to impose their version of a solution based on the failed Oslo process that died on October 7, or much before, with the two intifadas.

There is an enormous difference between attaching labels to a situation and taking the time to understand the reality beneath them. Colonel Richard Kemp, drawing on decades of military experience, recognises the complexities and security challenges Israel faces. Public figures such as Lewis Hamilton and others would do well to apply the same scrutiny before making sweeping accusations. Powerful words may attract headlines and reinforce existing narratives, but they do little to resolve complex problems. Understanding reality requires more than assigning blame; it demands evidence, context and intellectual honesty.

The difficult choices we face

Another recent report described the IDF’s use of Amazon’s facial-recognition technology to analyse millions of photographs of Palestinians.

For some, the headline alone is damning.

Surveillance. Artificial intelligence. Millions of photographs.

But surely we must examine the circumstances.

Israel faces organisations that have deliberately attacked civilians and taken hostages. Intelligence technology can help identify suspects and locate missing people.

That does not make every application acceptable.

Wrongful identification, civilian privacy and proportionality remain serious concerns.

The question should be whether the technology is necessary, reliable and properly controlled.

Extraordinary threats may demand extraordinary measures. But necessity must be demonstrated, not merely asserted.

The rains were coming

The recent flooding in Gaza offers another troubling example.

Winter was approaching. Heavy rain was foreseeable. Everyone knew that damaged tents and makeshift shelters would offer inadequate protection.

Yet families remained exposed, and heartbreaking photographs circulated around the world.

Children standing in flooded tents. Families trying to rescue soaked belongings.

Humanitarian organisations had warned about inadequate shelter and restrictions on essential supplies. Those failures deserve scrutiny.

But I find myself asking another question.

Why was there not a greater international effort to relocate vulnerable families before the storms?

Could temporary accommodation have been arranged in safer areas, or through voluntary refuge in Egypt and other countries?

There are genuine obstacles: security, border arrangements, accommodation and fears of permanent displacement.

Nobody should be forcibly relocated or lose their right to return.

But surely protecting civilians requires exploring every available option.

The photographs became powerful political symbols.

Yet would it not have been infinitely better for those children to sleep somewhere dry and safe than to become the subjects of another heartbreaking photograph?

I am not suggesting anyone deliberately preferred the photographs to prevention.

I am questioning a world where assigning blame sometimes gets more attention than finding practical solutions.

Compassion must lead to action, not merely accusation.

What does the Torah demand?

This brings me back to Jacob and Laban.

Rabbi Held reminds us that righteous objectives do not excuse dishonest behaviour.

Echoes of Rashi warns that habitual deception eventually destroys our capacity to recognise truth.

We face both dangers today.

We can become so convinced of our righteousness that we excuse everything our side does.

Or so suspicious of others that we reject everything they say.

Neither leads to truth.

Jacob eventually recognises that his relationship with Laban cannot continue. They separate, establish boundaries and acknowledge the reality of their differences.

They do not suddenly trust one another.

But they establish terms for moving forward.

Perhaps modern society needs something similar.

The ability to disagree without abandoning honesty.

The ability to recognise threats without losing our humanity.

And the willingness to examine reality before attaching labels.

The ladder still stands

Before encountering Laban, Jacob dreams of a ladder connecting heaven and earth.

God does not promise Jacob an uncomplicated life.

He promises His presence through it.

Perhaps that is the message for us.

We live in a complicated world, confronting real enemies, competing narratives and difficult moral choices.

But complexity does not relieve us of responsibility.

We must defend ourselves without surrendering our principles.

We must challenge accusations without automatically dismissing uncomfortable evidence.

And we must resist reducing human suffering to political slogans.

Truth is not established by the volume of an accusation or the popularity of a narrative. It requires evidence, context and moral courage.

The world may be full of Labans.

Our challenge is to recognise them without becoming like them.

Perhaps that is the real meaning of Jacob’s journey.

Not how to escape a complicated world.

But how to remain connected to heaven while confronting the reality of life on earth.

 

About the Author
Jeffrey Levine is a CFO, writer, and grandfather living in Jerusalem. He writes regularly on Jewish identity, ethics, and resilience, blending personal reflection with historical insight. His blog series “The Soul of Israel” can be found on the Times of Israel, Substack, LinkedIn, and other platforms. He is also the founder of Upgrading ESG—Empower Society for Good, which explores how business, faith, and sustainability can align for a better world. He is also the founder of PersoFi - Empowering AI Financial Automation for SMEs - www.persofi.com To learn about me, here is a link to my personal website - www.jeffreylevine.blog
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.