If I Was a French Jew

Photo by Martin V Moris on Flicrk Creative License, stating that Sarah Halimi had 22 fractures and was thrown out of a 3rd story building.

This month France opened hunting season on French Jews and decided that justice was no longer a value they cared about.

A judge dismissed all charges against a man who killed Sarah Halimi. The man beat her and called her a dirty Jew before throwing her out of a window. Just like thousands if not millions of other criminals and non-criminals who smoke cannabis every day, he smoked marijuana a few hours beforehand. In a stunning move, the judge accepted the argument that the same drug that millions of people smoke every day and do not kill soon after smoking, in this instance, made him kill a woman and he was not in charge of his actions.

This is an antisemitic ruling. If it wasn’t, then France would be required to set free all past and future killers and criminals who smoked cannabis prior to their crime. This ruling puts every French person and Jews in particular in danger. Because if all you have to do prior to killing a Jew is smoke or ingest some marijuana, then what would stop anyone from killing Jews or anyone else.

Jewish people around the world have gone to protest in front of the French embassies to demand justice. But it should not be just Jews who demand justice, every single French person who cares for justice, who feels that people should not get away with murder if they smoke Marijuana, should be in the street and demanding a reversal of the ruling.

But they are not. They do not care about this ruling because they know it only affects Jews and they do not care about Jews. They did not care during Vichi government, and they do not care now.

So what are French Jews to do if they are to demand that their lives be taken as seriously as those of any human being? Well, if I was a French Jew, I would boycott. If I was a doctor, I would not go to work. If I was an engineer, I would not go to work. If I was a businessman, I would shut down my business and send all people home.

This brazen attack on a Jewish life, requires an equally large response. It requires showing French people that Jews have an impact, and killing them has an impact. It shows that French Jews have self-respect and dignity and demand respect and equal protection under the law. And if they don’t get it, they will make it clear about what happens when Jews disappear.

That’s what I would do. But will the French Jews stand up for themselves in a way that actually gets the French people’s attention? I don’t know.

About the Author
Sam Livin was born in Soviet Union and grew up in San Diego. In 2012, he travelled the world photographing Jewish communities publishing a book called "Your Story Our Sipur." Today he continues to write about Israel and Judaism as he lives and studies business and ecology in Tel Aviv.
Related Topics
Related Posts