Israel’s Future Is Bigger Than the Secular-Liberal Middle Class
I read the Jerusalem Post article about Professor Almog Oz and his decision to leave Israel for Greece. As I understood it, Professor Oz acknowledges that he probably won’t ever feel truly at home in Greece. His roots are in Israel, and he describes leaving as painful. However, he believes that Israel has been taken over by religious Jews. He objects to both Charedim and Religious Zionists, and feels that the country no longer reflects his worldview. He explicitly says that his decision to move is based on values, and recommends that other secular-liberal Israelis leave for the same reason.
What I really took issue with was that Professor Oz went further, arguing that if enough of this particular segment of society leaves, Israel could face a crisis from which it might not recover. His premise is that secular-liberal Israelis are the backbone of the country’s innovation, intellectual life, and professional sectors.
I don’t dispute their enormous contributions. What I do question and object to is the assumption that Israel’s ability to sustain these sectors depends uniquely on this particular segment of society. Secular-liberal Israelis are neither the only ones currently contributing to these sectors nor the only ones capable of doing so.
Who gets the opportunity?
When certain groups are overrepresented in particular professions, does that necessarily mean others lack the qualifications or ability to succeed in those fields?
For example, the OECD’s 2023 Economic Survey discusses the importance of personal networks in high-tech recruitment in Israel. Networks formed through service in technological IDF units are an important gateway into this coveted industry, and many companies offer financial bonuses to employees who refer friends and acquaintances. The OECD notes that, although official data on military backgrounds are unavailable, studies estimate that 30–50% of high-tech workers have a background in technological roles in the IDF. It also warns that relying too heavily on this recruitment channel limits the pool of talent available to the industry.
This raises an important question. If professional opportunities depend heavily on personal connections, isn’t it possible that certain groups remain overrepresented partly because they already have access to those connections? I’m not suggesting that every hiring decision happens in this way or that the people hired are not qualified. But current representation should not automatically be mistaken for exclusive ability or potential.
What about the olim who are ready to contribute?
There are highly educated and qualified olim, including doctors, engineers, scientists, academics, technology professionals, and businesspeople, who arrive with years of professional experience. Yet many face obstacles in finding work in their fields. The Ministry of Aliyah and Integration has identified areas where skilled aliyah could help meet Israel’s workforce needs, including AI, research and development, advanced engineering, and defense technology. At the same time, it identifies licensing, language, and bureaucratic hurdles, as well as difficulties in getting employers to recognize and make use of olim’s qualifications and experience.
In other words, Israel needs skilled professionals, and there are skilled olim already here, as well as others who want to make aliyah and contribute. Yet it is not always easy for them to do so.
The capacity to build Israel belongs to all of us
Israel’s future does not belong exclusively to the secular-liberal middle class. Religious Zionists, Charedim, and olim should not be viewed as people who simply benefit from the contributions of others. Of course, the barriers and challenges are not the same for every group, but people from these communities are already contributing in many fields, and many more have the talent and drive to do so if given fair access.
Losing experienced professionals carries real short-term costs, and no one should minimize that. Still, there is an exciting possibility: What if more olim, together with Israelis who are deeply committed to this country and its future as a Jewish state, don’t simply fill the gaps left by those who choose to leave? What if we can help build an even stronger Israel?
Commitment to the Jewish people, our history, our land, and the future of the Jewish state can be a powerful motivation to contribute, innovate, and build.
Instead of focusing only on what Israel might lose when some people leave, we should also consider what it can gain by opening the doors to the many people who want to build its future.
We’re here to build, too.
