You Cannot Be A Jew Alone
“You cannot be a Jew alone.”
I heard those words in Warsaw, following one of the most difficult days of my life. I have thought about them constantly since.
Last month, my husband Jamil and I traveled through Poland and the Czech Republic with a group of emerging Jewish leaders as part of the Jewish Federation of Greater Indianapolis’ Maurer Koach mission. Generously funded by Linda and Todd Maurer, the program prepares the next generation of Jewish leaders to confront antisemitism through education and shared experiences. Jamil is a member of the third cohort, and I was grateful to accompany the group.
Together, we confronted the destruction of Jewish life during the Holocaust and met people building its future today.
At Auschwitz-Birkenau and Majdanek, I struggled to comprehend how much thought and effort human beings devoted to annihilating our people. Someone imagined these places. Others designed them, built them, and made them function. Every step involved deliberate decisions that brought the murder of millions into being.
The Nazis intended to erase us from the world. Entire communities were destroyed, taking with them centuries of learning, traditions, and ways of life. I kept thinking about the generations who should have followed, the children never born, and how much of our future was murdered, too.
Even after standing in those places, I cannot fully comprehend the enormity of the evil.
By dinner on the day we visited Auschwitz, I had been crying for hours.
That evening, we heard from a Hillel director serving Warsaw’s growing Jewish community. She had fled the war in Ukraine and was rebuilding her life in Poland, where she was helping young adults discover Jewish roots their families had been afraid to acknowledge under communism.
“You cannot be a Jew alone,” she told us.
Hours earlier, I had stood where our people were meant to have no future. Now I was listening to a woman describe how she was helping young Jews find theirs.
I have dedicated my career to building Jewish community. Today, I have the privilege of leading the Jewish Community Center in Indianapolis, a place where thousands of people come together each year to learn, celebrate, build relationships, and find belonging.
I thought I understood how much that work mattered. After everything we had witnessed that day, I realized there were depths to that responsibility I was still discovering.
When she finished speaking, I was still crying. She approached me, placed her hand on my shoulder, and embraced me.
“I can tell this is hard for you. Don’t worry. We will be okay.”
“There is nothing I’ve been more sure of,” I replied.
I meant it.
Here was a woman who had been forced to leave her home, rebuilding her own life while devoting herself to the future of our people. She had noticed my pain from across the room and came to comfort someone she barely knew.
I spend my days helping build community for others. That evening, I felt what it means to be carried by it.
I keep returning to that moment because it captures something I hope every person who walks through the doors of a JCC experiences: the feeling of being seen, cared for, and connected to something beyond themselves.
During our travels, we visited Jewish community centers in Krakow and Warsaw. Although separated by thousands of miles from the JCC I lead in Indianapolis, I recognized something familiar in both places. People were coming together to build relationships, celebrate Jewish life, and create a sense of belonging.
In Poland, where Jewish communities were nearly extinguished, those efforts carry extraordinary significance. Young people are discovering identities their families once felt compelled to hide. Jewish life is finding new expression in places where the Nazis intended for it to disappear forever.
There is something profoundly moving about witnessing that renewal.
It also reminded me how much we can take for granted in communities where Jewish institutions have existed for generations. I grew up at a JCC in Birmingham, Alabama, and now lead one in Indianapolis. In both places, I have seen how deeply these institutions shape people’s lives, often in ways they may not fully appreciate until years later.
The belonging I experienced growing up did not happen by accident. Generations before me invested their time, resources, and energy in ensuring there would be a vibrant Jewish community for those who followed.
Today, that responsibility belongs to us.
Our JCC in Indianapolis, like so many Jewish community centers around the world, welcomes people of different faiths and backgrounds. Through shared experiences, people who might otherwise never cross paths come to know one another as friends and neighbors.
I believe those relationships are especially important as antisemitism continues to threaten Jewish communities. Hatred becomes harder to sustain when it is directed toward people we know, people whose children play with ours, and people we care about. Relationships alone cannot eliminate prejudice, but they can give us reasons to challenge it and stand beside one another when it matters.
At the same time, Jewish community must be about far more than responding to antisemitism. Our children deserve to inherit a Jewish identity shaped by joy, connection, tradition, and pride, rather than one defined primarily by the hatred others have directed toward us.
We cannot undo the destruction we witnessed in Poland or recover the generations of Jewish life stolen from us. We can, however, take responsibility for the Jewish future being built right now.
I think about the young Jews in Warsaw discovering their identities, the people rebuilding Jewish communities in places where so much was lost, and the generations who will follow us. I think about my own son and the Jewish world he will inherit.
The survival of the Jewish people is extraordinary, but survival alone cannot be our ambition. We have a responsibility to ensure Jewish life is vibrant, meaningful, and accessible to those who will carry it forward.
That work happens in Jewish community centers, synagogues, schools, Hillels, and wherever people make the deliberate choice to build Jewish life together. It happens through the relationships we cultivate and the care we show one another, often in moments that seem small until we realize how much they matter.
I still cannot make sense of what we witnessed. I suspect I never will. Yet I returned to Indianapolis more certain than ever that building Jewish community and ensuring our people have a future is work worthy of everything we can give it.
“You cannot be a Jew alone.”
She had told us what that meant. Then she put her hand on my shoulder and showed me.
