More Than My Share: Lessons in Gratitude from Rav Mordechai Willig
In June 1974, Rabbi Zevulun Charlop called three young rebbeim into his office and asked for a volunteer. Yeshiva was launching a program that brought high school seniors into a college-level shiur. Teaching boys a year younger than everyone else looked like a step down, and no one raised his hand.
So Rabbi Charlop wrote on three slips of paper, dropped them into a hat, and had each man draw. Two slips were blank. The third read Kodesh LaHashem.
The rebbe who drew it went home and told his wife he had just received his first demotion. That rebbe was Rav Mordechai Willig.
I heard this story on a recent episode of Aseh Lecha Rav, the YUTorah series in which Rabbi Aryeh Lebowitz, Dean of RIETS, sits down for long conversations with the Yeshiva’s senior roshei yeshiva. Rav Willig insisted that the hour be about his rebbeim, not about himself. He mostly kept to that. But the story that emerged, almost despite him, was about something larger than any one rebbe: how a life is actually built, and the gratitude that ought to follow.
Gratitude as an Inheritance
The story really begins a generation earlier. During the Great Depression, Rav Willig’s father was in the middle of high school at the Rabbi Jacob Joseph School (RJJ) on the Lower East Side when the school shut down. It could no longer pay its teachers.
His grandfather brought the boy uptown to Yeshiva and asked them to take him in. When they asked what tuition he could pay, the grandfather admitted, embarrassed, that he could not even put enough bread on the table for his children. The Yeshiva took the boy for nothing.
He stayed through high school, college and semicha, which he received in 1940 from Rav Moshe Soloveitchik and Dr. Bernard Revel, just months before both passed away. And he never forgot who had taken him in. Decades later, whenever his son started to criticize the institution, his father would not hear it: They took me in.
Rabbi Lebowitz quipped that the Yeshiva never made a better investment. He’s right. But I was struck less by the investment than by the father. Hakarat hatov is not a feeling we have once and move past. It is a posture we choose to hold for a lifetime, and in this family it became the inheritance.
The Slip in the Hat
That “demotion” in 1974 turned out to be, in Rav Willig’s words, the biggest promotion of his life. The seniors entering his shiur were the strongest boys coming out of MTA. For thirteen years, the best talmidim in the Yeshiva came to him first. Many of them are today’s rebbeim and roshei yeshiva.
In 1987, the script flipped. Rabbi Charlop told him he was being promoted to a higher shiur, to make room for a young Rav Mayer Twersky. Rav Willig did not want to move. He offered to let Rav Twersky teach above him instead. He lost the argument; as he put it, it is hard to win an argument with Rabbi Charlop.
So the demotion was a promotion, and the promotion felt like a demotion. Even the move he resisted gave him twenty more years of talmidim he still speaks of with love. What looks like a loss on the day it happens rarely turns out to be one.
The Road Not Taken
In the summer of 1973, Rav Aharon Lichtenstein invited Rav Willig to join Yeshivat Har Etzion. In Israel for his sister’s wedding, he delivered a shiur l’dugma, a sample shiur before the roshei yeshiva, and was offered the job on the spot, house included. (Rav Lichtenstein also critiqued the shiur. He always did.) Back home, an offer from Rabbi Charlop at YU was waiting. A child’s health, some inertia, and a long talk with his wife decided it. He stayed. “The road not taken,” as Rav Lichtenstein liked to say.
Then there was the payphone. For more than a decade, Rav Willig learned b’chavrusa with Rav Hershel Schachter, first at night in Rav Schachter’s apartment, then in the afternoons in the beit midrash. But as Rav Schachter became the address for the entire community, the phone outside the beit midrash kept ringing, and he kept getting pulled away. Eventually, the chavrusa could not continue.
That loss sent Rav Willig into Yadin Yadin, the advanced semicha program in dayanut. Years later, that training became the foundation for his work on the Beth Din of America.
We are poor judges of our own stories while we are inside them. The blank slip, the job offer declined, the phone that won’t stop ringing: none of them announces what it will become. Rav Willig has one name for all of it, siyata d’shmaya. “You couldn’t have written the script if you tried,” he said. Then he called it what he believes it is: not a string of quirks, but the master plan of Hakadosh Baruch Hu.
“I Couldn’t Say No”
One refrain ran through the entire conversation: I couldn’t say no.
He didn’t want to teach at Stern College, but the Rav asked. That reluctant yes turned into some fifty years of teaching halacha at Stern, on and off, and he is still teaching there today, now on Zoom.
The RCA prenup, perhaps his greatest gift to the Jewish people, grew the same way. When he became rav of the Young Israel of Riverdale in 1974, he resolved that there would never be an agunah in his shul. Fifteen years later there was one. The husband was barred from the shul before Sukkot and still refused to give a get by Pesach. Rav Willig told his talmidim that they had to find a solution. From that one painful case came a document that has spared countless women from being chained.
He never dreamed of serving on the Beth Din of America, but when asked to step in for Rav Gedalia Dov Schwartz, he couldn’t say no. He hadn’t even wanted to do this podcast. Rabbi Lebowitz told him it would help Klal Yisrael, and that settled it.
I know this side of Rav Willig personally. Over the years, I have called him more times than I can count. My wife and I have turned to him for advice on personal matters, and he has always made the time, always listened, always answered with respect. I cannot remember him ever saying no. And I know I am one of countless people who could say exactly the same thing. What moves me is not only that he says yes, but how consistently he says it, to everyone, for decades.
Listening to the podcast, I finally understood where that comes from. Rav Willig’s entire life was built from yeses he never planned. To him, the person on the other end of the phone is not an interruption. He may be the next slip of paper in the hat.
Torah That Travels Unseen
The most moving moment came at the very end. Rav Willig closed by saying that all of us, in whatever we do, work for the Ribbono Shel Olam. Rabbi Lebowitz then recalled that Rabbi Yisroel Kaminetsky used to tell them at DRS, before every difficult decision and every hard meeting: You don’t work for me. You don’t work for the board. You work for the Ribbono Shel Olam. Rabbi Lebowitz had never known where that line came from. Now he did. Rabbi Kaminetsky had been one of Rav Willig’s standout talmidim, arriving in his shiur from MTA as an eleventh grader.
A sentence spoken in a shiur decades ago had quietly shaped decisions in another yeshiva, for people who never knew its source. Then, unexpectedly, it found its way back to the man who first said it.
Rav Willig told a similar story about himself. For five years he sat in the Rav’s shiur and never knew what the Rav thought of him. Only when he went to Boston to be menachem avel did the Rav’s daughter, Dr. Tova Lichtenstein, tell him that her father would look into certain talmidim’s eyes to see whether they understood. He was one of them. It was worth the trip to Boston, Rav Willig said, just to hear that sentence.
Every rebbe, every teacher and every parent knows what it is to wonder whether anything we say is landing. Most of the time we will never find out. Our words travel on without our names attached. But they travel.
And sometimes, as Rav Willig discovered in Boston and again in this conversation, they come home. When a teaching finds its way back to the one who first taught it, the rebbe learns what he could never have known on his own: that it mattered. Telling him so is hakarat hatov in its purest form.
More Than My Share
Throughout the conversation, Rav Willig described his blessings with a phrase drawn from Rashi on this week’s parsha: more than my share. When Leah gives birth to her fourth son, she names him Yehuda and declares, Hapa’am odeh et Hashem, “This time I will thank Hashem” (Bereishit 29:35). Why only now? Rashi explains that Leah knew Yaakov would father twelve tribes from four wives, so each could expect three sons. With a fourth, she said, natalti yoter mechelki: I have received more than my share. Now I must give thanks.
That is how Rav Willig understands his life. A father taken in without tuition. A slip of paper in a hat. A job offer declined. A chavrusa ended by a ringing payphone. Talmidim who became gedolim. Children who all chose, as he put it, to go into the family business. He said, with complete sincerity, that he does not understand what he did to deserve it.
Leah teaches that gratitude begins when we stop measuring what we are owed. Once we see that we have been given more than our share, only one question remains: what will we do with it? Rav Willig closed the conversation with his own answer. Don’t ask what Hakadosh Baruch Hu can do for you, he said. Ask what you can do for Him.
Few of us will ever learn from rebbeim like him or serve on the Beth Din of America. But each of us has our own slips of paper and our own roads not taken. Each of us, if we are honest, has received more than our share. The question is whether we will notice it, thank Hashem for it, and say yes when He asks something of us in return.
