Parham Shahrjerdi, Jean-Luc Nancy and the Crisis of Modernity VI
Parham Shahrjerdi is an Iranian writer, critic, translator and editor, born in Tehran in 1980 and now living in exile in Paris. He has translated Maurice Blanchot, Marguerite Duras, Georges Bataille, Pascal Quignard and Antonin Artaud into Persian. He founded the website Espace Maurice Blanchot and the publishing houses Nashr-e Paris and Namomken, which distribute e-books banned in Iran, and he co-edits the review Hors-Sol. He is also a practising psychoanalyst, and is currently publishing, with the Lacanian psychoanalyst Colette Soler, a book on Blanchot and analytic speech (Sur la parole analytique).
The best-known idea of Jean-Luc Nancy, (1940–2021), the “inoperative community” set out in La communauté désœuvrée (1986). That book has yet to be translated into Persian.
Nancy is nonetheless present in Iranian intellectual life. Sharjerdi wrote with him on Iran in lundimatin (“Iran: la double peine”). He also sits on the editorial team of Philosophy World Democracy alongside Kamran Baradaran, translator of Baudrillard, Gramsci, Virilio and Žižek, who has himself interviewed Nancy. The journal’s website carries a section titled “The Grace of Jean-Luc Nancy.”
This installment explores three questions: how a Blanchotian in exile reads Nancy, what the Persian language does to Nancy’s vocabulary, and where, at the end, psychoanalysis enters.
From Blanchot to Nancy
Shahrjerdi’s intellectual home is Blanchot. Beyond the website and the translations, he is vice-president of the Association des amis de Maurice Blanchot. The detail matters, because Nancy’s thinking of community began as a conversation with Blanchot: La communauté désœuvrée followed Blanchot’s La communauté inavouable (1983), and Giorgio Agamben answered both in The Coming Community (1990).
Nancy’s core claim is easily stated. A community is not a body fused around an essence, a nation, a religion or a common project. Such “operative” communities, in his analysis, end in exclusion and violence. Community is rather the condition of existence itself: to be is to be exposed to others, “singular plural,” as his 1996 book puts it.
The Heidegger precedent, once more
As with Derrida in the previous installment, Nancy did not arrive on virgin soil. Ahmad Fardid had fused Heideggerian suspicion of technology with a call to return to an authentic, pre-Western essence. Reza Davari Ardakani turned it into a philosophical justification for the Islamic Republic’s suspicion of the West. Daryush Ashuri spent his career dismantling the slogan, and Bijan Abdolkarimi has excavated the same terrain.
Nancy reads the same Heidegger in the opposite direction. A Persian commentary published by Radio Zamaneh after his death notes that he understood Being as Mit-Sein, being-with, but refused to follow Heidegger in treating life in common as inauthentic. For Nancy, authenticity belongs to being-together. Seen from there, the road from Fardid to Nancy is less a rupture than a fork: one Heideggerian inheritance can yield a return to essence, another an exposure without essence.
Shahrjerdi stands at the far end of this landscape. Fardid and Davari worked close to the centres of power and the university. Shahrjerdi works from exile, from small presses and from banned files, and according to a biographical note published by Lundi matin, he left Iran when the Ministry of Intelligence was organizing the serial assassination of intellectuals and writers.
Against testimony, against fantasy
Invited to write the text for Les Réso_nances, an exhibition of twenty-five Iranian artists at the Galerie Oraxe in Paris (June 25 to July 13, 2026), he explains that he wanted to avoid a trap: making the artists speak in place of their works and turning them into witnesses. It is hard not to hear Nancy here: singularities that share a world without sharing an essence. The philosophical gesture is consistent: do not fuse the Iranians into a single body that can be spoken for.
Nancy in Persian: a reception by the periphery
Shahrjerdi’s Nancy is not a Nancy already in circulation, and the Persian record is thinner than one might assume. Nancy’s translators are many and scattered. Baqer Parham translated L’Évidence du film, his book on Kiarostami; Afshin Hafizi, Justice, Love, Beauty (Nashr-e Markaz, 2013), from the English; Ehsan Kianikhah, The Fall of Sleep (2016); Ehsan Pourkhiri and Hossein Tayyeb, his dialogue with Alain Badiou, German Philosophy (2021). The most prolific is Narimân Jahânzâd, who translated an interview volume, the essay After Fukushima: The Equivalence of Catastrophes (2021), Marie-Eve Morin’s study of Nancy and an introduction to his thought.
Essays on populism and democracy circulate on websites, among them an interview on democracy, the people and sovereignty translated by Shidan Vasiq. Kamran Baradaran counts Nancy among the figures he has interviewed. The community trilogy, for its part, enters mostly by its title, and the vocabulary is not stabilized, as we shall see. An interview carried by the Iranian outlets IBNA and CGIE asks why Nancy has been so little noticed in Iranian thought, and is titled in a way that calls him, in the end, a Derridean philosopher. It is a telling label for a thinker whom Derrida himself honoured with a whole book. The reception is largely a matter of diaspora media and small presses rather than of the university.
Community in Persian: ommat, mellat, jâme’e
This is the terrain on which any Persian reading of Nancy, Shahrjerdi’s included, must operate. The problem of saying “community” in Persian begins before any translation, because there is no neutral word for it. Each candidate carries its own history.
Ommat (امت) is the Qur’anic umma, the community of believers. It comes from an Arabic root that also gives umm, mother, and imâm, the one who stands in front: etymologically, the umma is a body oriented toward a direction and a leader. Mellat (ملت), borrowed from Arabic milla, once a religious community, has become the ordinary word for “nation” and “people.” Jâme’e (جامعه) and ejtemâ’ (اجتماع) come from a root of gathering and cover “society” and “the social,” while anjoman names an association or assembly.
Constitutional language shows how the first of these can be put to work. Article 5 of the Constitution speaks of the guardianship and leadership of the umma (velâyat-e amr va emâmat-e ommat), and Article 11 invokes the Qur’anic verse that the umma is one. In Nancy’s terms, this is the operative community: it has a direction, a leader and a work, the realization of a divine order. The umma is, of course, a far older and broader notion than the state’s use of it, and it is this political use that Nancy’s critique reaches.
Now the titles. Radio Farda renders La communauté désœuvrée as ejtemâ’-e ‘amal-nâpazir (اجتماع عملناپذیر), roughly “a community that cannot be put into action,” while another translation simply transliterates communauté. A translation of an interview on Iran Liberal speaks of komunte-ye bi-asar (کمونتهی بیاثر), “a community without work or effect.” The choice between ‘amal and asar is not neutral. ‘amal sends the reader toward deed and action, including the religious register of faith and works, whereas asar evokes the finished work, the product, the artwork. Œuvre is both.
A review of Morin’s book published by IBNA glosses Nancy’s community as dar-eshterâk-budan (being-in-sharing) and bâ ham budan (being-with-one-another). Eshterâk (اشتراک), participation or sharing, comes from the same root as shirk, the association of partners with God, the gravest sin in Islamic theology and the opposite of tawhid, divine oneness. To name Nancy’s being-in-common with the word for sharing is quietly to summon the doctrine of the One. It is the same collision as the one noted in the previous installment: a philosophy of multiplicity applied to a theology of the One.
The Persian lexicon is therefore lopsided. The positive name of community is already occupied by the Qur’anic term, while Nancy’s own can be said only by negation: bi-asar, ‘amal-nâpazir. French does the same with désœuvrée, but in Persian the negation stands against a word that is not neutral. The question for translators is less which word renders communauté than which word remains free of the umma.
From community to trauma
If Persian resists Nancy at the level of the word, Shahrjerdi’s other register, psychoanalysis, offers another way to say what the umma cannot. In June 2026, the review of the École de psychanalyse des Forums du Champ lacanien published his reading of Colette Soler’s Traumatisme$, and he has taken part in an evening devoted to her Lacan et l’être-femme. From Soler he draws a distinction between two registers of trauma. The first is the traumatic event. The second is a more radical real, owing nothing to contingency: the entry into language, the “troumatic” One (Lacan’s coinage, from trou, hole, and trauma) that no speaking being escapes. This trauma is incurable, he notes, but not without recourse, and what opens there is “an ethics without lament, without promise” (“une éthique sans plainte, sans promesse”).
The operative community, whether the umma or any other, promises exactly the wholeness that the “troumatic” One rules out. Nancy had his own passage through Lacan, from Le titre de la lettre (1973, with Lacoue-Labarthe) to L’« il y a » du rapport sexuel (2001), and the thread may be less accidental than it looks. Community as exposure and finitude, trauma as the incurable wound of language: both unwork the dream of a fused body.
A community that cannot be hurried
This is where Shahrjerdi’s position becomes legible. He does not offer Persian a ready-made word for Nancy’s community, and perhaps no such word exists yet. He offers a place from which to work on the problem: an exile’s vantage point, a Blanchotian attention to what cannot be made into a work, and an analyst’s conviction that the wound of language is not a promise to be redeemed.
A question I asked Nancy myself in December 2020, during France’s second lockdown, bears on the same point. The first lockdown had been about containing the devastation of the virus, and the talk was of immunisation, even of communisation. The second was about containing the desolation of expropriation and recession, with talk of copropriation. I asked whether the so-called collaborative economy brings the gratuity and luxuriance that Valentin Husson, in L’Écologique de l’histoire, considers necessary, or exactly the opposite.
Nancy declined to judge: real forms of society and life, he said, need “a great deal of time” to come to light. Those practices are often “very interesting and stimulating,” but they remain inside what he calls automation, a system “self-finalized” in two ways, by an exponential technical growth and an equally exponential appropriation of wealth. The first already threatens itself through ecological disaster, the second through “a moral, social, aesthetic and human disaster” whose extent we are only beginning to see. A community that merely collaborates is still an operative one, working toward an end it has given itself. The inoperative community cannot be had by project, and it cannot be hurried.
For a modernity that Iranian thought has so often debated as a choice between a return to essence and an imitation of the West, this is a third possibility: a community that holds together without being fused. Whether Persian can find a name for it remains open. That the question is being asked, in small presses and diaspora reviews rather than in the university, may be the surest sign that the crisis of modernity has not ended, but has changed its vocabulary.

