Parshat Vayetzei: Alone, and Not as Alone as You Think
Vayetzei opens with a person at rock bottom. Yaakov leaves Be’er Sheva, alone, running for his life from a brother who wants to kill him. He has no home anymore, no plan, nothing but what he can carry. Night falls in the middle of nowhere, and he lies down in the dirt with a stone under his head for a pillow, and he sleeps.
That is where this parsha starts. Not in a palace, not on a mountaintop. On the ground, in the dark, alone, with a rock for a pillow. And I think that is exactly why it has so much to say to anyone who has ever had a night like that, the kind where everything familiar is gone and you are lying there in the dark wondering how you got here and whether anyone even knows where you are.
The dream on the ground
And it is there, at his lowest, that Yaakov has the dream. A ladder set in the ground with its top reaching the heavens, and angels going up and down on it, and Hashem standing over him with a promise. הנה אנכי עמך ושמרתיך בכל אשר תלך. I am with you, and I will protect you wherever you go. I will not leave you.
Think about the timing of that. The vision does not come when Yaakov is strong and settled and surrounded by people who love him. It comes the night he has nothing, lying in the dirt. That is when heaven opens. That is when he is told, you are not alone, and you never were.
There is something in that for all of us. We tend to assume that if we were really being held, really being watched over, we would feel it, especially on the good days. This parsha says the opposite. The ladder came down on the worst night, to the most alone person, in the least holy-looking place. Sometimes the presence we are most sure has abandoned us is closest exactly when we feel most forsaken. We just cannot always feel it in the moment.
“And I did not know it”
Yaakov wakes up and says something painfully honest. אכן יש ה’ במקום הזה ואנכי לא ידעתי. Surely Hashem was in this place, and I did not know it.
He was not alone that night. He only thought he was. The presence was right there the whole time, and he could not feel it until afterward, until he woke up.
That describes something so many of us know. When you are in the pit, you are certain you are completely alone. Certain no one sees you, no one is with you, nothing is holding you. And sometimes, only later, looking back, you realize there were hands on you the whole time that you could not feel. The friend who kept texting. The person who sat with you and said nothing. The small chesed you were too numb to notice. Hashem was in this place, and I did not know it. Being unable to feel that you are held is not the same as not being held. The feeling lies. The presence was real.
So if you are in a place right now where you feel truly alone, I cannot promise you will feel differently tonight. But I can tell you what this parsha promises, which is that the feeling of being abandoned and the fact of being abandoned are not the same thing. You may be far less alone than every cell in your body is telling you.
Leah, and the ache of not feeling loved
And then the parsha turns to someone whose pain is quieter and, for a lot of people, even more familiar. Leah.
The Torah does not hide it. Yaakov loves Rachel. Leah is the one he did not choose, the one given to him through deception, the one he wakes up next to and did not want. And the Torah says something that aches. וירא ה’ כי שנואה לאה. Hashem saw that Leah was unloved. He saw it. Somebody saw it.
Watch what Leah does with that pain, because it is one of the most human arcs in the Torah. She has children, and she names them out of her longing. The first, Reuven, because now surely my husband will love me. The second, Shimon, because Hashem heard that I am unloved. The third, Levi, because now, this time, my husband will attach to me. Three children, three names, all of them a cry from a woman who just wants to be wanted, who keeps hoping the next thing will finally make her feel chosen.
Anyone who has ever felt like the second choice knows that voice. Maybe if I do this, they will love me. Maybe if I give more, achieve more, need less, I will finally be enough. Leah pours herself out, child after child, trying to earn a love that will not come the way she wants it to. And it is painful to read, because so many of us have lived it, chasing a sense of being enough through someone else’s approval that never quite arrives.
Leah’s turn
But Leah’s story does not end in that ache, and this is the part I most want you to see. She has a fourth son, and she names him Yehuda, and the reason she gives is completely different from the first three. הפעם אודה את ה’. This time, I will simply thank Hashem.
Something shifted. The first three names were all about him, about earning his love, about why this child would finally make her chosen. The fourth is not about him at all. It is gratitude, plain and full, for what she actually has. She stops trying to extract love from the one person who is not giving it the way she needs, and she turns toward the blessing that is already in her arms.
That is a kind of healing. Not that the hard relationship magically fixed itself. It did not. But Leah found something solid that did not depend on being chosen by the person who would not choose her. And it is no accident that the name she gave out of that gratitude, Yehuda, is the name we still carry. We are Yehudim, Jews, named for the moment a hurting woman stopped chasing a love that would not come and chose gratitude instead. Our entire identity is built on the turn Leah made.
If you are exhausting yourself trying to be enough for someone who cannot seem to see you, Leah is not telling you to stop wanting love. She is showing you that your worth was never actually in their hands. There is solid ground that does not depend on being chosen by the one person withholding it. She found it. So can we.
Angels going both ways
One more thing, back at that ladder. The Torah says the angels were going up and down on it. Our commentators asked the obvious question. If they are angels of heaven, they should be coming down first and then going up. Why does it say up and then down?
One answer has stayed with me. The ladder is a picture of a life. And a real life is not a straight climb upward. It is angels going up and down, up and down. Good stretches and hard ones. Days you are rising and days you are sinking. The ladder does not promise you will only ever go up. It promises that the ladder is planted in the ground and reaches heaven, that even in the down parts you are still on it, still connected top to bottom, still held.
You do not have to be on the way up to be on the ladder. The downs are part of it too. The whole thing is anchored in the dirt, right where Yaakov was lying, and it still reaches all the way to heaven.
What we can carry
None of this is me having it figured out. It is just what I want us to carry this week.
• The feeling of being alone is not proof that you are. Yaakov was most held on the night he felt most abandoned. You may be far less alone than you can feel right now.
• Notice the hands you could not feel. Often only later do we see who was with us in the dark. The text, the quiet company, the small chesed. Let yourself look back and find them.
• Stop trying to earn love from someone who will not give it. Leah shows that your worth was never in their hands. You do not have to keep paying for a love that is not for sale.
• Turn toward the blessing already in your arms. Gratitude for what is actually here is not denial of what hurts. It is the solid ground Leah finally stood on, and it holds.
• Remember the ladder goes both ways. A real life has ups and downs. The down days do not mean you fell off. You are still on it, still held, still connected all the way up.
Yaakov went out alone, into the dark, with a stone for a pillow, sure that everything was lost. And right there, in the lowest place, heaven opened and told him he was never alone. If you are in your own version of that night, lying in the dark wondering if anyone knows where you are, hold on. Hashem was in this place, and I did not know it. The presence is real, even when you cannot feel it. Especially then.
If any of this is sitting close to home, please reach out. In the US you can call or text 988, the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, any hour of any day. In Israel, ERAN’s emotional first-aid line is 1201. Wherever you live, a local crisis line, your doctor, or one person you trust is a good place to start. On the loneliest night, you do not have to be alone with it.
Dedicated l’ilui nishmat Zev (Will) Shakin, z”l, who loved Israel and lived v’ahavta l’reacha kamocha. May his memory be a blessing, and may his light keep reaching the people who need it.
Mental Health in the Parsha is a weekly series on the weekly Torah portion and what it can offer us right now. These thoughts are meant for reflection and conversation, not as a replacement for professional mental health care.
