Gottfried Hutter
Member of the European Academy of Sciences and Arts

Religion’s Potential to Contribute to Peace in the Holy Land

A dream image for the UN-Center in Vienna on the occasion of the Interfaith Harmony Week of 2017 C.E.: the PM of Israel, Benyamin Netanyahu, re-enacting the scene behind the origin of “Israel”.

Everybody knows about Martin Luther King’s dream: on August 28, 1963 at his great march on Washington he spoke about it and you will remember his famous words “I have a dream!”

Today I would like to tell you about another such dream, a dream of peace in the Holy Land!

But let us start with today’s reality, because reality is the source of my dream:

On Friday, January 6, 2017, the Top Imam of Palestine, Dr. Mahmoud Habbash, the supreme Sharia Judge of Palestine, declared: moving the US embassy to Jerusalem, as the new American President Donald Trump announced, is a ‘declaration of war’ on Islam. Dr. Habbash did not say “war on Palestine”, he said “war on Islam”.

What is the connection between the US-embassy and Islam?

Jerusalem is the connection. For Muslims Jerusalem is a holy city. Jerusalem is their holy city. Jerusalem is the city of the prophets, who came before the Prophet Mohammed. That is why the archangel Gabriel brought the Prophet Mohammed to Jerusalem – and from there he lifted him up into heaven to meet with all the Prophets who had come before him – in his famous Night Journey. That is why Jerusalem is one of the most holy cities of Islam. Besides Mecca and Medina there is Jerusalem!

This was uncontested – until there was a State of Israel!

This is why none of the Muslim States agreed when the United Nations in 1947 said they would provide a home for the Jews in their ancient Biblical homeland.

Because the ancient Biblical homeland of the Jews has become the heartland of the Muslim Umma a very, very long time ago, nobody could take it away from the Muslims! Nobody could take Jerusalem away from the Muslims.

And now along comes a new American President, and he wants to move the American Embassy in Israel to Jerusalem! He wants to take Jerusalem away from the Muslims, so it seems to Muslims. This is to declare war on Islam! Not war on Palestine, but war on Islam!

For an Israeli, this is nearly impossible to understand. But I just tried to make it understandable even for an Israeli, because, if an Israeli makes the mental effort to see the whole matter from a Muslim point of view, he will understand.

But could a Muslim also understand the point of view of an Israeli?

Could a Muslim ever leave the point of view of the Umma in compassion for someone he is used to seeing as an enemy?

A Muslim professor at a German university, Dr. Mouhanad Khorchide, wrote a book entitled “Islam means compassion”!

He states that a Muslim can feel compassion even for an enemy, because an enemy, too, is a human being like himself.

And so, he can feel compassion even with an entire people, the Israelis.

But now, just imagine:

The PM of Israel, Benyamin Netanyahu, doing what the name-giver of Israel, Jacob, did.

The story is not present in the Qur’an; many Muslims may not know it. So please let me tell you the story, for not only does it explain the meaning and origin of the name “Israel”, it tells of the reconciliation between two very important brothers who were deadly enemies; and that is precisely what makes it the forerunner, indeed the perfect model of a solution to today’s conflict between Israel and the Muslim Umma!

Back then, nearly four thousand years ago, Abraham’s grandson Jacob had deceived his brother Esau. Following his and his mother’s intuition he had even deceived his father Isaac by pretending to be Esau in order to get his father’s blessing. To get this blessing meant to be the one to receive God’s promise to their father Abraham of becoming the founder of a great people, which would be a blessing for the entire world. That was what Jacob wanted. And in order to get that he was ready to cheat. And he succeeded! Understandably, Esau was angry. He wanted to kill Jacob.

Jacob had to flee. He spent decades in exile. But eventually he had to return if he wanted to be the person who would carry out the promise contained in the blessing – that he would become the father of the people Abraham had seen in his vision.

So, Jacob was approaching, returning from exile. And his brother Esau awaited him – with 400 armed men, ready to kill him!

Jacob was desperate. He spent his last night before the showdown alone in prayer. And he encountered an angel who fought with him. But Jacob did not give in. He kept insisting on getting God’s blessing – and that he was given – and with it he received a new name: “Israel” – which means “the one who fought with God and prevailed”.

And the next day Jacob knew what he had to do:

When he approached his brother Esau, Jacob prostrated himself before him seven times – and he expressed his regret.

And his brother Esau was moved.

He lifted Jacob up and embraced him – and he forgot about his armed men.

This is the story of the original Israel – a lecture for today’s Israel!

And this is my dream.

Just imagine an Interfaith Harmony Week in a not too distant future in New York at the United Nations Building. The PM of Israel, Benyamin Netanyahu, is one of the participants, another is the Imam of the Al Azhar in Cairo, Dr. Ahmad Al-Tayyeb, the symbolic head of Sunni Islam, and the third participant is Ayatollah Khamenei, the symbolic head of Shia Islam.

Just imagine these three persons being the main actors in the great assembly room of the United Nations in New York. Just imagine a grand ceremony there with the Prime Minister of Israel doing what Jacob had done nearly four thousand years ago, when he reconciled with his brother Esau. Following in the footsteps of Jacob, the Patriarch who gave Israel its name, the Prime Minister of Israel will prostrate himself before the Imam of the Al Azhar and before Ayatollah Khamenei, and he will apologize!

He will express his regret over the absolute distress of the Jewish people in the year 1947, when they just had escaped – while six million of them had been killed in the Holocaust! He will express his regret about the absolute existential necessity to establish a Jewish homeland in the midst of the Muslim Umma, and he will express his regret about the need to abstain from the Sharia rule of subordination under the superiority of Islam, while at the same time recognizing that principle for the rest of Umma territory. And he will appeal to the authorities of the Muslim Umma, both Sunni and Shia, to understand the exceptional plight of the Jews at the time of the founding of the State of Israel.

While that would not have been possible back then – Netanyahu will now ask for Islamic mercy and compassion!

Can you imagine?

After I told this story to an Egyptian Imam in Germany – one known to be a member of the Muslim Brotherhood – he was very moved and he said, if Netanyahu were to do that, the Muslim Umma would welcome Israel and tell Netanyahu what Esau had told Jacob: Welcome, the territory is big enough for both of us. Go, establish your Jewish homeland – and if you really need it, you may even build your new Temple. We will find a way.

That is reconciliation. That is peace, true peace!

About the Author
Gottfried Hutter is a member of the European Academy of Sciences and Arts, studied Catholic theology, history and political science in Salzburg, Austria. For five years he lived in the US. Insights there enabled him to meet a highly respected Sufi Master. One year with him in Egypt confirmed his understanding of the basic unity of all religions. He became a psychotherapist. Today he mentors severely traumatized Muslim refugees from the Middle East. 9/11 provided the idea and impetus to write this book: 100 Years of Middle East Conflict. HONORABLE PEACE. How Can Lasting Peace be Secured between the Muslim World and Israel?
Related Topics
Related Posts