“Settling the Score” – A Fundamental Obligation of the Jewish State

For centuries, the Jewish people have endured the darkest trials of human history—surviving pogroms, expulsions, and the unthinkable horrors of the Holocaust—facing violence, persecution, and genocide from time immemorial. The establishment of the State of Israel was more than just the founding of a nation; it was the reclamation of sovereignty after millennia of statelessness and vulnerability, a turning point that provided not only a homeland but a powerful assurance: that never again would Jews be left defenseless. The notion of “settling the score” is not rooted in vengeance, but in the sovereign right of a nation to defend its people and to ensure that those who threaten their safety are held accountable. This is not merely a response to violence, but a steadfast commitment to justice, safeguarding the dignity and security of Jews worldwide.

This assurance is intertwined with the responsibility of the Jewish State to protect its citizens and Jews worldwide. The promise that those who seek to harm Jews will face consequences serves as a powerful deterrent against future attacks, sending a clear message that the era of impunity has ended.

Beyond deterrence, this principle is about upholding justice and preserving moral order. In a world where antisemitism is on the rise, and acts of violence against Jews are increasingly frequent and severe, a clear and unequivocal response to such acts is essential. This is not about revenge; it is about ensuring that justice is served and that the safety of Jews is maintained.

However, this approach is not without its challenges. Critics argue that an uncompromising stance could lead to an escalation of violence or perpetuate a cycle of retaliation. History has shown that tit-for-tat responses can sometimes perpetuate conflict rather than resolve it. This concern is valid, as the goal of any policy should be to achieve lasting peace and security, not just temporary deterrence.

To address this, the Israel’s leadership must carefully calibrate its responses, ensuring they are focused on preventing future harm rather than simply exacting retribution. Diplomatic efforts and strategic alliances should complement military responses, helping to de-escalate tensions and create a broader framework for peace. This balanced approach can mitigate the risk of further violence while maintaining a strong stance against those who wish to harm Jews.

The broader geopolitical implications of this policy must also be considered. Israel’s actions are closely watched on the international stage, and its policies can significantly impact its relationships with other nations. A strategy perceived as overly aggressive could strain diplomatic ties and lead to international condemnation from even Israel’s closest allies, potentially isolating Israel and weakening its global position. Therefore, it is crucial that the Jewish State communicates its actions clearly, emphasizing the justice and necessity behind them while demonstrating a commitment to peaceful solutions.

Ethically, the balance between justice and mercy must also be weighed. The Torah teaches us to “pursue justice,” but it also emphasizes compassion and the importance of seeking peace. The Jewish State must embody these values by not only holding perpetrators accountable but also striving to create conditions that reduce the likelihood of future conflicts. This could involve investing in education, fostering dialogue, and supporting initiatives that promote mutual understanding.

In this light, “settling the score” is about restoring balance and upholding justice, but it must be pursued with wisdom and a recognition of the broader context. It ensures that the Jewish State fulfills its most fundamental obligation: to protect its people and guarantee that those who seek to harm them will face consequences. However, this commitment must be tempered with a strategic and ethical approach that seeks not only to defend but also to build a more peaceful future.

Looking ahead, the State of Israel must remain steadfast in this commitment, while also envisioning a more secure and peaceful world. In doing so, Israel must not only defend against those who seek to harm but also inspire hope for a future where peace is possible. This vision of resilience—where justice and compassion coexist—will be the legacy that ensures the Jewish people, and all who cherish peace, will thrive in a world free from the shadows of hatred.