The Army That Bears The Ark – Two Years of War
The Army that Bears the Ark is Invincible
1. Israeli Exceptionalism
A story is told about a rabbi, a priest, and an anti Zionist academic who are traveling on a plane about to crash, but there are only two parachutes left for the three of them. The rabbi turns to the anti Zionist and says I want to be the bigger man here: take my parachute. It has Hebrew writing on it, and I bought it in Israel. Seeing you use it to save your life may very well change your heart.
Laughing, the anti Zionist grabs it from the rabbi’s hands and says fine with me. That was incredibly magnanimous of you, the Priest said to the Rabbi. I can’t believe you showed such grace. The rabbi replies: that’s what you think – he just jumped out of this plane with my Talis Bag!
Jews need to have a dark sense of humor. How else do we cope with all the hatred and vitriol directed against us? Some dark humor, and some Divine Providence.
How else to describe what we’ve witnessed these two years, if not Divine Providence. If you had told me after October 7th two years ago, when Israel was at the lowest point in its history, that they would go on to defeat all of their enemies systematically: from Hezbollah in the north, to the Assad Regime’s fall in Syria, to Israel finally being able to hit the head of the snake in Iran and take out their nuclear program, and their leading military leaders in just 12 days…miraculous. And yet, still, the struggle with Hamas goes on.
It’s easy for us in the diaspora to worry about Israel, to seek how we can support it. Instead, I want to flip the script on that today. I want to discuss how Israel can help us. How we can learn from it. Because the sobering truth is, that despite all of its challenges, I see the Jewish future in Israel as being far more bright than that of the diaspora. In my former place of residence in New York City, we’ve seen the leading candidate for Mayor, in the city with the largest Jewish population outside of Israel, endorse the call to “Globalize the Intifada”, which means to target Jews everywhere. I never thought such a thing could be possible. It’s a scary time to be Jewish in America.
In their book entitled: “The Genius of Israel: The Surprising Resilience of a Divided Nation in a Turbulent World”, by Dan Senor and Saul Singer, the authors address the following questions:
“How has a small nation of 9 million people, forced to fight for its existence and security since its founding and riven by ethnic, religious, and economic divides, proven resistant to so many of the societal ills plaguing other wealthy democracies? Why do Israelis have among the world’s highest life expectancies and lowest rates of “deaths of despair” from suicide and substance abuse? Why is Israel’s population young and growing while all other wealthy democracies are aging and shrinking? How can it be that Israel, according to a United Nations ranking, is the fourth happiest nation in the world? Why do Israelis tend to look to the future with hope, optimism, and purpose while the rest of the West struggles with an epidemic of loneliness, teen depression, and social decline”?
One elegant answer is given by the Israeli philosopher Micah Goodman. Israel, he told Senor and Singer, “is a small country with a big story… Big enough to give you meaning and small enough for you to have influence on it.” The United States, Goodman elaborated, is a big country with a big story, but relatively few Americans will ever have opportunities to shape that story in significant ways. A little country—a Belgium or a Slovakia—may be small enough for an individual to make a difference. But a difference for the sake of what”?
I dispute Goodman’s notion that America is too large a country for any of us to make a difference here. But his point is still well taken.
2. He Who Has a Why Can Endure Any How
Hersh Goldberg Polin was an American Israeli hostage in Gaza. After a year in captivity, Hersh was murdered by his captors in a tunnel, along with five other holy hostages, as IDF forces closed in on their position.
Hersh’s fellow captives who survived and have since been released have testified about the inspiring mantra which he taught them, and which helped them to endure their ordeal: “He who has a Why can endure any How”. Freed hostage Ohr Levy has said that Hersh would lead his fellow hostages each morning in going around the room, and asking what are you living for today, what is your why? And they would repeat that line each morning as their mantra: He who has a why can endure any how.
The inspirational Rachel Goldberg Polin says that her son took that idea from the Holocaust survivor Victor Frankl, who wrote the book “Man’s Search for Meaning”. And she further says that Frankl himself got that basic idea from the philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche.
But I say that it appeared first in the Torah. It’s a line that we say every time that we remove the Torah itself from the Ark, and which said this very morning, from Bamidbar 10:35-36 –
וַיְהִ֛י בִּנְסֹ֥עַ הָֽאָרֹ֖ן וַיֹּ֣אמֶר משֶׁ֑ה קוּמָ֣ה | ה וְיָפֻ֨צוּ֙ אֹֽיְבֶ֔יךָ וְיָנֻ֥סוּ מְשַׂנְאֶ֖יךָ מִפָּנֶֽיךָ
וּבְנֻחֹ֖ה יֹאמַ֑ר שׁוּבָ֣ה ה רִבֲב֖וֹת אַלְפֵ֥י יִשְׂרָאֵֽל
“And it was when the ark would travel, that Moses would say, arise oh Lord, and scatter your enemies, and let your haters flee from before you. And when it came to rest he would say, Repose O Lord, among the myriads of thousands of Israel”.
I’ve often joked that there’s no greater disconnect between a popular melody and its words. Imagine if we sang these words in English: “Ariiiise ohhh Looord and scatter your enemies!! And leeet your hater flee from befooooore youuuu!”
These two verses are marked off in every Torah scroll by two inverted letter Nuns, which form brackets around these words. This led the rabbis in the Talmud to say that this short two verse passage constitutes its own separate Book of the Torah unto itself. That’s how important it apparently is.
When removing the Torah from ark, after the verse “VaYehi Bin’Soa”, we quote the words of Isaiah 2:3 –
Ki MiTzion Teitzei Torah U’Dvar Hashem Mi’Yerushalayim.
“For out of Zion shall the Torah come forth, and the word of the Lord from Jerusalem”.
If I could paraphrase what these two verses mean: “When the ark would travel, Moses would say: destroy your enemies” means: “He who bears a Divine sense of purpose can conquer any challenge”.
Ki Mi’Tzion Teitzei Torah means – “For our country exudes Divine purpose, and the meaning of life itself from our capital city”. These are two statements of immense confidence in our national identity. And we say them every time that we remove the Torah. But do we ever reflect on them? Hersh made me reflect on them in this way.
The power of these verses was conveyed perhaps most strongly in our time by the great Jewish sage Steven Spielberg, in his movie “Indiana Jones: Raiders of the Lost Ark”. There’s a scene towards the beginning of the movie, where Indiana and his colleague Marcus Brody are briefing two US army officers, Major Eaton and Colonel Musgrove, about the Ark:
[Scene: They all look at an old painting of the Hebrews devastating their enemy with the Ark]
Eaton: Good God!
Brody: Yes, that’s just what the Hebrews thought.
Musgrove: [points to a beam of light in the painting] Uh, now what’s that supposed to be coming out of there?
Jones: Lightning. Fire. Power of God or something….
Brody: Oh, yes. The Bible speaks of the Ark leveling mountains and laying waste to entire regions. An army which carries the Ark before it… is invincible.
3. The Army That Carries the Ark Before It is Invincible.
Israel is a small country with a big story. Perhaps Israel doesn’t always live up to its grand story; but a grand story, rooted in the timeless Torah, is what it channels. And that can’t be defeated.
Our enemies, of course, also have a sense of Divine purpose. But it’s been said that if Jewish theology can be summed up in two words, those words would be: ethical monotheism. Hamas is very strong in the monotheism. Just not in the ethical part. The lesson of the movie Raiders is that when the Nazis try to use the holiness of the Ark, while dressed in the garb of the Jewish High Priest, it only backfires upon them and melts their faces off. Hamas called their mass terror attack the Al Aqsa Flood, invoking the holiness of that spot. Their blasphemy backfired upon them as well, and now all of their leaders and an outright majority of their tens of thousands of foot soldiers from October 7th are all dead.
We’ve all read about the immense and unprecedented challenge that the IDF faces in Gaza. Hamas terrorists cynically embed themselves within the civilian population, they take command in schools and in hospitals. General David Petraeus was the commander of US and Coalition Forces in Iraq 15 years ago. He then became a director of the CIA, and is the author of the book “Conflict: The Evolution of Warfare from 1945 to Ukraine”. He has been described as the world’s leading expert in counterinsurgency warfare.
General Petraeus declared rather ominously almost two years ago, shortly after October 7th, that Israel in Gaza faced: “The most fiendishly challenging and difficult urban operation [in the world] since 1945”. I remember feeling unexpectedly moved when I read that, but I couldn’t figure out why at the time. I only finally figured it out while writing this speech: Because it’s fitting that the nation with the strongest Why should be presented with the most challenging How. Because only they are equipped to handle it.
There’s a line that we were taught in the hospital chaplaincy that some find comforting to say, but that you should actually avoid saying: “God doesn’t give you any challenge which you aren’t able to handle”. Don’t actually say that to people, we were told, because they might feel in that moment that they really don’t have the strength to handle it, and you won’t actually be comforting them. And yet, the line is cliché with all religious groups precisely because we do intuit some level of truth to it, don’t we?
I think it does apply to Israel. God has presented it with immense challenges which demonstrate to the world how only Israel is equipped with a national ethos strong enough to handle them. In that way, Israel is a light unto the nations. A light isn’t always popular. A light can be painful and blinding. But it’s still a light of truth.
4. The Yarden
Someone I am keeping close to my heart today is Yarden Bibas. On October 7th, Yarden’s parents in law Yossi and Margit Silberman were murdered in Kibbutz Nir Oz. Yarden was taken captive, and his wife Shira and two sons Ariel and Kfir were taken captive separately. The red headed toddler and baby Ariel and Kfir and their mother Shira were murdered in captivity, and became a symbol for all of the hostages, and for the tragedy of October 7th itself.
After a year in captivity, Yarden was released in one of the hostage deals. How can anyone possibly move on in his situation? When I saw pictures of him riding in the helicopter home, he was holding a sign thanking the People of Israel for fighting for him. And I had the sense that he would be ok. I couldn’t articulate why at the time, but now I can: Because he’s returning to the only nation with a national ethos strong enough to hold his pain. Israeli society has a sense of purpose strong enough to hold his pain along with him. And that will make his healing possible.
We come to shul each year and the rabbi teaches how to best repent. Hersh taught me that I’ve never really taught why. Isn’t the why obvious? To be a better Jew, a better person? Yes, those are the general reasons. But you need a personal reason. My personal reason is so that my kids will look up to me as I look up to my own parents. I never even articulated that before. What’s your why? What is your grand story? Have you ever even thought of it before? Hersh challenges us to reflect on that for this year.
The college campus morons chant “From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be Free”. In viral clips that you can find online, these kids are asked to name which river and which sea, and they can’t even do so. Most Jews can do so. The Mediterranean Sea in Hebrew is called The Great Sea (The Yam HaGadol). The River is called the Yarden.
When Yehoshua led the People into the Promised Land, the Yarden split for them, and they carried the Ark of the Covenant across it. They conquered the city of Yericho by carrying the Ark and blowing the shofar. And when the Shofar sounded the Tekiah Gedolah, the walls came tumbling down. The American Negro Spiritual song based on that Biblical passage was of great comfort to Black American slaves in captivity. They were able to fantasize about the power of being free men and women with a divine sense of purpose. You can’t keep people like that down for too long, as The South would soon discover.
“The Bible speaks of the Ark leveling mountains and laying waste to entire regions. The Army that carries the Ark before it is invincible”. So let’s not worry about Israel, because they will be fine. Let’s take instead, this year, what we can learn from Israel, which is to develop a Why which can endure any How. And let Hersh be our inspiration for this year in that regard. Shanah Tovah.
—
From sermon delivered at KI Synagogue first day Rosh Hashanah 5786.

