The Election We Forget– Until the Bill Comes Due
Most pleaded. Some screamed. Others threatened. Whatever the year or the weather, crowds reliably packed the meeting room of our town council when they received their first property tax statements. As deputy mayor, I was a logical target; people assumed I had the power to trim, delay, or eliminate something – anything – from the municipal budget to provide relief.
But beyond a certain point I was powerless, as were all municipal officials. Under New Jersey state law, the mayor and council have no say in the expenditures of the school board, an independently elected body with an ironclad claim on over 40% of property tax revenue. And New Jersey is no outlier. Across America, an estimated 45% of total public K-12 education revenues come from local governments, with 80% of this local cash drawn from property taxes. Exact percentages vary by state, district, and the formulas that apportion state aid, but nowhere is public school a bargain.
Faced every year with this hit to homeowners’ wallets, we could offer little more than sympathy…and frustration. Sympathy because we knew the taxes were burdensome. Frustration because we also knew that voter turnout in our school board election was 12%. In other words, 88% of voting-eligible residents ignored that body – until they saw its price tag.
Our sorry statistic was typical: Nationwide, voter turnout for school board elections sinks as low as 5%, especially when the contest dates are out of sync with federal elections. The majority of American voters don’t bother to vote for candidates who, if elected, will make some of the most impactful decisions in their communities.
Those impacts aren’t just financial. They influence the social attitudes, civic values, and intellectual climate of the communities around them.
AND THEY AFFECT JEWISH FAMILIES WHOSE CHILDREN NEVER SET FOOT IN A PUBLIC SCHOOL.
Here’s how:
1. Who Can Afford to Live Here?
The most obvious issue is affordability. When public schools are supported so heavily by property taxes, their costs can put otherwise attractive towns out of reach for many Jewish families. When middle-income families are priced out, the local Jewish population skews toward the better-off. A less economically diverse Jewish community can mean narrower perspectives, fewer opportunities for participation, and a diminished sense of solidarity.
And when the only Jewish residents in a pricey town are highly affluent, it feeds the stereotype that “all Jews are rich.”
2. Who Gets to Decide What Children Read?
“Curation” is the polite word for the practice better known as book bans, which proliferated during the last few years. Granted, most bans have been limited geographically and demographically, but they are pernicious whenever and wherever they occur. And while relatively few book battles make the national news, attempts to censor books continue apace: the American Library Association tracked over 4000 unique titles challenged in 2025, the second highest number ever documented by the group. Advocates for public school blacklists believe it is dangerous to expose kids to troubling human behaviors like violence, oppression, victimization, or racism. In their view, such exposure abrogates the right of parents to…well…pretend these challenges don’t exist.
Of course, public school library books should be age-appropriate and, where necessary, subject to parental permission. Religious schools should be free to set their own standards. But overzealous community bans replace informed analysis with silence, and make teachers shy away from class topics that might prompt parental complaints. The result: young people are poorly prepared to recognize and grapple with evil in the real world awaiting them. Avoid Shakespeare, and Shylock is just another slur. Ignore The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, and its conspiracy theories pass as political discourse (Jews are controlled by outside interests! They’re disloyal to America!)
Why does this matter to Jewish parents whose kids are schooled elsewhere?
Because there are ripple effects in the public square. When local schools get into the banning business, their efforts – typically well publicized across social media – can make community librarians nervous. Public libraries are independent of schools, but few of these professionals have a taste for cultural combat and may try to head it off. It’s easier to quietly remove, say, Bernard Malamud’s novel The Fixer – a Pulitzer prizewinning portrayal of antisemitism – than to argue about whether it’s overly violent or profane (a real debate that got contentious in Beaufort, South Carolina). And such purges limit what residents can read, learn, and share, robbing everyone of knowledge that might help them understand each other.
3. How is Antisemitism Punished?
In 47 states, school boards hold significant sway over disciplinary policies within their districts. When it comes to antisemitic acts against students or staff, this means that policies – and their enforcement – can be wildly inconsistent from state to state, county to county, district to district. One school may excuse Nazi salutes or Holocaust jokes as ordinary teasing, while another penalizes such conduct as harassment. Depending on the nature and frequency of the behavior, remedies can range from detention or suspension to requiring the perpetrator to write a “reflection” essay.
I’m no expert on punitive reflection, but I doubt that a budding Jew hater can be reformed by homework. If your child were subjected to antisemitic torment in school, wouldn’t you want the offender held accountable in a way you see as meaningful? School board members directly influence what punishment is considered meaningful – and how consistently it is applied.
Again, the concern isn’t limited to Jewish students in public schools. The schoolhouse isn’t a sealed environment; children grow up to become our neighbors, coworkers, and civic leaders. What they learn or observe about Jews in school doesn’t stay in school. If student miscreants get nothing more than a slap on the wrist for antisemitic insults, threats, ridicule, or worse, they’ll be emboldened to show their malice on the street, in the park, or around their neighborhoods. And their victims in community spaces may be older and more vulnerable than classmates.
We Jews have learned, often painfully, that attitudes tolerated in one generation can become dangers confronting the next. That’s why we can’t ignore the institutions that shape our neighbors’ children, even when our own children are educated elsewhere.
We can’t expect mayors and town councils to override decisions of people we don’t bother to choose. We cannot blame school boards for policies we fail to scrutinize.
School board elections may be easy to forget. Their consequences are not.

