The Holocaust Isn’t Jewish History
For those tracking antisemitism in U.S. educational institutions from K-12 to the university level, the November 18 story about Concordia University Professor Erica Lehrer’s planned lecture at Penn State titled, “Do We Need to Decolonize Holocaust Museums?”, sent many online Jewish communities into a new round of despair and exasperation.
“Decolonization” has become a trigger word for Jews around the globe for whom it translates as dispossession of our lived experience both as individuals and as a collective. Couple that word with the increasing popularity of Holocaust inversion, in Former Ambassador Deborah Lipstadt’s words: “soft-core Holocaust denial” that “weaponizes the memory of Jewish suffering against Jews themselves” and, for some of us, it’s been a distressing couple of days.
It turns out, however, that if one takes the time to learn a bit more about what this lecture sought to unpack, Professor Lehrer and the Director of Jewish Studies Program, Professor Tommaso M. Milani, were not ill-intentioned. In the discourse on museum collections, that inciting term, decolonization, “explores the ethical questions concerning artifact collections…how museums care for the objects taken from Jewish individuals and communities and the responsibilities institutions have when pieces on display were never returned to survivors or their descendants when their descendants asked for them.”
As Jews in the year 2026, after all that has happened in the past three years, we know better than most that context matters. Conversely, knowing that college campuses are currently under great scrutiny and an obscure lecture on how Holocaust museums collect and keep their inventory will dominate social media algorithms, Professor Lehrer and Professor Milani could have been more thoughtful about the word choice for this particular lecture’s title.
Nevertheless, in the words of economist and Nobel Laureate Paul Romer, “a crisis is a terrible thing to waste.” So let’s turn this one into an opportunity for more discussion on the Holocaust, its history, and its troubled role in fighting against antisemitism in our post-October 7 reality.
In my little corner of the world, the South Bay of the Greater Los Angeles Area, each week parents reach out with upsetting stories occurring on school campuses. Swastikas appearing in bathrooms or fashioned out of a banana (true story, although I didn’t see it myself); lesson plans blaming Jews and Israel for 9/11; Social Studies textbooks misrepresenting Jewish history with blatant factual errors.
From the district superintendents to the on-site specialists, fortunately, there is no argument in these parts that we have a problem. For the parents in my community, their request of school administrators is to bring Holocaust survivors to campus, to visit the Museum of Tolerance, to increase the length of the Holocaust unit in the history book.
Liaising between schools, parents, and students, I also hear stories of how reading Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl or a visit to the Holocaust museum only increases the slurs slung at Jewish students online or at school. The shared boxes get checked by parents and teachers alike, but the problem is hardly solved.
We should not be teaching the Holocaust as a way to learn about Jews. The Holocaust is not Jewish history. Jewish History is the Torah, the story of Jewish civilization in the Land of Israel and in Diaspora. Jewish history is what Jews have made happen with the cards they have been dealt; the positive and negative consequences of the choices made by forefathers and foremothers, judges, prophets, kings, rabbis, politicians, lay leaders, and the everyday Jew. Jewish History is not a victim narrative, it is full of agency and taking responsibility for repercussions.
We should teach about the Holocaust to understand how democracy can be misused by a dictator with an intricate and elaborate scheme for world domination by fomenting hatred against those who can be classified as “other”. Symphony, opera, theater, tea salons, art museums, architectural masterpieces, sexuality studies – all of the crowning achievements Western civilization could claim for itself in the mid-20th century, proved to be empty status symbols in the hierarchy of humanity.
The Holocaust is European history. It is the history of Western Civilization imploding upon itself. After centuries of colonization of communities and civilizations whose alleged savagery and primitiveness were the justifications for their domination by European powers, Europe itself descended into the most base and violent behavior it claimed to be better than. It is the history of the murder of 11 million victims of Hitler’s Nazi regime: Jews, Roma, People of Color, LGBTQ People, Disabled People, Catholics, Communists, and Dissenters.
Jewish Holocaust history is the testimony, the novels, the films, the plays, and trauma therapies created by survivors and their descendants to bear witness and give dignity to ancestors. Jewish Holocaust history is the story of how we have lived, how we came back to life, and how we live. It is not how we died or were killed.
When we’re advocating for the inclusion and safety of our Jewish children in school and online, we have to insist on something other than the visit to the Holocaust museum. Those seeking to rewrite Jewish history have identified the Holocaust as our Achille’s Heel. The more time we spend reacting to the provocations and the inversion, the less energy we have to meet with educational decision makers to help them adjust their approach to fighting antisemitism. In the words of author Dara Horn, people love dead Jews. What’s our plan to get them to love the living ones more?
