Avi Rubel

The Imperative of Leaning Into Israel Now

At JFNA’s General Assembly this month, I had countless conversations that circled back to the same question. It usually came with a raised eyebrow: You intend to bring thousands of unengaged, unaffiliated young couples to Israel in the next few years? I won’t pretend it’s easy. Filling our buses right now is hard work, but we have trips from throughout North America scheduled for the coming months.

But what makes this work difficult is what makes it matter so much.

Honeymoon Israel serves young couples with at least one Jewish partner in the early stages of their lifetime commitment, just as they’re building a life together and deciding what role Judaism and Israel will play. The recent Project Prism research from the Jim Joseph Foundation highlights how conversations about Israel can create barriers to Jewish engagement for some young adults. While recent events have inspired some to deepen their involvement in Jewish life, others have pulled back or become more selective about how they engage.

Among those who have reduced or changed their engagement, many describe conversations in Jewish spaces as hostile or unproductive, express concern about one-sided messaging, or feel there is little room for nuance. The findings suggest that, for some young adults, the barrier is not necessarily a lack of interest in Jewish life or Israel, but whether Jewish spaces make room for them to engage on their own terms, with their questions and perspectives welcomed rather than discouraged.

One response to these tensions is to sidestep conversations about Israel altogether. But we believe there is another path: to lean into the complexity rather than shy away from it. That’s what Honeymoon Israel is choosing to do. We’re inviting couples into the conversation, creating the community and the space to experience Israel, explore difficult questions, and move beyond binaries. Most critically, we’re helping them feel and understand what it means to belong to the Jewish people and to have a place in the conversation about its future.

We recognize that some couples may not be interested in engaging with Israel through Honeymoon Israel. But we believe there is a meaningfully sized population who are curious and searching for belonging in some way, yet face barriers that make opportunities for Jewish engagement feel inaccessible, unwelcoming, or misaligned with their values. These are the couples we have the opportunity to reach.

Honeymoon Israel Board member, Howard Zack, who also sits on the board of the Hartman Institute, shared Donniel Hartman’s recent teaching about what Donniel calls the Torah of Dayenu. As Hartman explains, our tradition teaches us to have gratitude for what is, even as we strive for what could be.

That ability to hold appreciation and aspiration together is precisely what we hope to make possible in couples’ relationships with Israel. Not a loyalty test, and not a demand to set aside difficult questions, but an opportunity to engage with Israel in all its complexity.

The conflicts and controversies that dominate today’s headlines can make it difficult to see Israel’s broader history, its founding aspirations, and its place in the story of the Jewish people. Honeymoon Israel has an opportunity to help couples encounter this broader history, including the reasons Israel was established and the ideals upon which it was founded.

Israel’s Declaration of Independence, written in the shadow of the Holocaust, articulates both the Jewish people’s right to self-determination and the aspirations of the new state. It declares “the natural right of the Jewish people to be masters of their own fate, like all other nations, in their own sovereign State.” And it promises that Israel “will be based on freedom, justice and peace as envisaged by the prophets of Israel” and “will ensure complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex.”

Our continuously adapting trip itinerary now begins with couples delving into Israel’s Declaration of Independence. Rather than telling them what to think, we invite them to ask what a Jewish state should be, how it should act, and what it should strive to become. They encounter the Declaration’s commitments to freedom, equality, and peace, and consider how those aspirations intersect with the complexities of Israel today.

These are commitments we must strive to hold together, even when doing so is difficult. They reflect a Jewish tradition that calls us to pursue justice and aspire to be “a light unto the nations.”

So as Honeymoon Israel gears up for major growth in the coming years, I’m focused on the question our founding Board Chair and current Board member, Joe Kanfer, from the Lippman Kanfer Foundation for Living Torah, put on the table: What is the job to be done? What is the critical need we are meeting and responding to?

When Mike Wise and I started Honeymoon Israel in 2014, the need was clear. The just-published Pew study of American Jewish life showed 72% of non-Orthodox couples were intermarrying and not finding a place in Jewish life. We created an on-ramp to Jewish community with Israel at its heart that welcomed couples as they were. Since then, we’ve brought 3,500 couples to Israel, and the impact has extended far beyond the trip owing to the extensive follow-up work that is built into our model. Five years later, 80% of alumni report that Judaism is an important part of their family identity, and 82% remain close with couples from their cohort. What begins as a shared experience in Israel becomes Jewish families and local communities that continue to grow long after the trip ends.

Our experience demonstrates what is possible when couples are invited to engage with Israel in all its complexity. Last year, nearly two-thirds of participants who arrived feeling emotionally disconnected from Israel or unsure of their connection returned home feeling connected. Even among those who arrived feeling disconnected, 83% said HMI presented Israel-related content with nuance, matching the rate among those who arrived already connected. In other words, couples don’t have to arrive with positive feelings about Israel to appreciate an approach that welcomes complexity and difficult questions.

But the impact extended beyond their relationship with Israel. Among participants who arrived feeling disconnected or unsure about Israel, the share who felt a sense of belonging to the Jewish people grew from just 39% before the trip to 71% afterward. These findings reinforce our belief that creating space for nuanced engagement with Israel can help couples build not only a deeper connection to Israel, but also a stronger sense of belonging to the Jewish people.

We’ll continue to focus on couples who might otherwise struggle to find an on-ramp to Jewish life but who are committed to undertaking the journey. We’ll continue bringing 20 couples from the same city, together on one bus, because building local community is at the heart of our work. Some couples will grapple with issues of basic Jewish identity, and others will grapple with peoplehood and Israel. They’ll arrive with different backgrounds, experiences, beliefs, and questions. Together, they’ll experience Israel, build relationships with one another, and return home in community poised to continue those conversations and deepen their sense of belonging.

Gratitude and invoking Dayenu for what is, doesn’t at all spare us from striving for what could be, which is outfitting thousands more emerging Jewish families with the invaluable affirmation that they belong, strengthening local Jewish communities through diversity and new leadership and nurturing a generation whose relationship with and love for Israel is resilient enough to hold both appreciation and difficult questions.

About the Author
Avi Rubel is the CEO of Honeymoon Israel, which he co-founded in 2014 to creating a more welcoming and inclusive Jewish community through trips to Israel for groups of diverse couples. Honeymoon Israel has brought over 3,000 couples to Israel from 23 cities. Prior to leading Honeymoon Israel, Avi was the founding North American Director of Masa Israel Journey, bringing more than 10,000 North Americans to Israel annually. Avi also spent more than a decade working on Jewish community development in the former Soviet Union with Hillel and the American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee. Avi served as a United States Peace Corps volunteer for two years in Kyrgyzstan and earned a Master in Public Policy from Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.