Mamdani’s Rikers Gamble: Compassion as a Slogan, Chaos as a Plan
Let’s begin with what is not in dispute. Rikers Island is a disgrace. More than 120 people have died there since 2014, and the complex now operates under federal receivership. No serious person defends it as it stands. So, the question was never whether to close Rikers. The question is whether Zohran Mamdani knows how to close it without turning the streets, shelters and subway platforms of New York into the jail’s overflow psychiatric ward. Eleven months into his tenure, the answer is becoming painfully clear.
Start with the arithmetic. A 2019 city law requires Rikers to close by August 2027. The four borough jails meant to replace it are not finished. The mayor himself told reporters that meeting the deadline is “practically impossible” (amNewYork) and laid the blame on his predecessor. Fine. But a mayor who concedes that the replacement beds will not exist in time, and who nonetheless stages a ceremony each time a building on the island goes dark, is not running a closure plan. He is running a press calendar. The city is now awaiting his “major announcement” on the path forward. Before the applause begins, New Yorkers are entitled to one simple answer: where, exactly, will roughly 7,000 people go?
Justice pursued justly
The Torah commands, “Justice, justice shall you pursue” (Deuteronomy 16:20). The Chassidic master Rabbi Simcha Bunim of Peshischa (c. 1765 to 1827) famously read the doubled word as a demand about means as well as ends: pursue justice, but pursue it justly. A righteous goal reached by reckless methods is not righteousness. That is the whole problem with this mayor’s Rikers policy in a single verse.
The Torah also gives us a model of what humane custody actually requires. The cities of refuge (Numbers 35) sheltered those who had killed unintentionally, protecting them from vengeance while protecting the community from them. The Talmud (Makkot 10a) insists that these cities be established only where there is water, where there are markets, and where there is a sufficient population, and that if the population dwindles, it must be replenished. The same page teaches that a student sent into exile must be accompanied by his teacher, because the Torah promises the exile that he shall “live” there (Deuteronomy 4:42), and a life without learning is no life. The Mishnah (Makkot 2:5) and the Gemara that follows (Makkot 10b) add that the roads leading to these cities were aligned and maintained, and that signs reading “Miklat, Miklat” (“Refuge, Refuge”) were posted at every crossroads. In other words, the Torah built the infrastructure first. The refuge had to be ready, provisioned and staffed before anyone was sent there. Mamdani has the sequence backwards: he is tearing down before he has built.
The patients nobody is planning for
I’ve been practicing psychology for over four decades, and this is where my alarm is greatest. According to a report by the Data Collaborative for Justice at John Jay College and the Katal Center, roughly 60 percent of people in New York City jails are flagged as needing mental health care, and about 22 percent carry a serious mental illness such as schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. The Vera Institute of Justice reports that by August of this year, more than 1,400 people on Rikers had been diagnosed with serious mental illness, against fewer than 1,000 specialized mental health beds. The City Council itself has described Rikers as one of the largest providers of psychiatric care in the country!
Let’s be precise, because precision is what this debate lacks. Those numbers are an indictment of the city, not of the patients. People with serious mental illness are far more often victims of violence than perpetrators, and the city’s own Independent Budget Office found that detainees with mental illness were less likely to face violent felony charges than those without.
Our tradition understood this two thousand years ago. The Mishnah (Bava Kamma 8:4) rules that the shoteh, the person without sound mind, is not liable for the harm he causes, while anyone who harms him is liable. Yet the same mishnah opens with a sober warning: an encounter with such a person can be dangerous. The rabbis held both truths at once. The mentally ill person is not culpable, and the community still bears a duty to protect itself and him. That is not cruelty and it is not sentimentality. It is responsibility.
Behavioral science says the same thing in the language of data. In 1939, British psychiatrist and geneticist Lionel Penrose published a cross-national study of European statistics in the British Journal of Medical Psychology showing an inverse relationship between the number of mental hospital beds and the number of prisoners. The pattern is now called Penrose’s law: as psychiatric beds decline, prison and jail populations rise, and the reverse. American deinstitutionalization confirmed it at enormous human cost. The asylum did not disappear; it moved into the county jail. Close the jail without building the hospital, and the asylum simply moves again, this time to the subway platform. Decarceration rhetoric without forensic psychiatric beds, supportive housing and intensive community treatment teams is not reform. It is abandonment with better branding.
The Torah has a word for this kind of foreseeable negligence. “When you build a new house, you shall make a parapet for your roof, so that you do not bring blood upon your house if anyone should fall from it” (Deuteronomy 22:8). The obligation is not merely to avoid pushing someone off the roof. It is to build the railing before anyone climbs up. And a second verse closes the escape hatch: “Do not stand idly by the blood of your neighbor” (Leviticus 19:16).
When compassion shatters its vessels
Kabbalah offers the deepest diagnosis of what is going wrong. In the account of creation taught by kabbalist Rabbi Isaac Luria (Ari Zal), the divine light poured into vessels that could not contain it, and the vessels shattered: shevirat ha-kelim. The light was not the problem. The lack of capacity to hold it was. Compassion, chesed, is holy, but chesed without gevurah, without boundary, structure and limit, does not heal the world. It breaks it. Rashi, commenting on the first verse of Genesis and drawing on the midrash, teaches that God first contemplated creating the world through the attribute of strict judgment alone, saw that such a world could not endure, and joined to it the attribute of mercy (Rashi on Genesis 1:1; compare Pesikta Rabbati 40). The inverse is equally true. A world run on mercy alone, without judgment, cannot endure either.
Mamdani speaks fluently the language of chesed. What his administration has not supplied are the vessels: the beds, the clinicians, the housing, the supervision. According to the Independent Budget Office, in 2014 about 17 percent of those held pretrial on Rikers faced violent felony charges; by 2023 the figure was 46 percent. The easy releases have already happened. What remains demands gevurah: sober, unsentimental planning. Instead, the signals from City Hall run in one direction. A former Rikers detainee now runs the Department of Correction. An emergency order curtails solitary confinement. Police are no longer automatically dispatched to 311 complaints about homeless encampments. Each decision can be defended alone. Together, they describe an administration whose instincts run reliably toward the person in custody and away from the commuter, the shopkeeper and the family waiting on the platform.
Pirkei Avot (3:2) preserves the teaching of Rabbi Chanina, the deputy High Priest: pray for the welfare of the government, for were it not for the fear of it, a man would swallow his fellow alive. Rabbi Chanina lived under Rome. He had no illusions about state power. He simply understood that public order is the precondition for every other good, including mercy.
Why Jewish New Yorkers are watching
Readers of this site will ask why a jail in the East River is a Jewish concern. The answer is in the NYPD’s own data: in 2025, Jewish New Yorkers were the targets of more hate crimes than all other groups combined. Jews in this city are not abstractly at risk. They are the most frequently attacked minority in it.
Into that environment steps a mayor who declined to condemn the slogan “globalize the intifada,” who has supported the BDS movement, who vowed to arrest Israel’s prime minister should he set foot in the city, and who this summer released a video branding him a war criminal and the architect of a genocide. When a mob gathered outside Park East Synagogue chanting for intifada, Jewish leaders found the mayor’s response closer to justification than condemnation.
Social psychology explains why this matters even when no law is broken. Prejudice is regulated less by private belief than by perceived social norms: people express hostility when they sense that the people around them, and especially the people above them, will tolerate it. The clearest demonstration comes from a study by Christian Crandall, Jason Miller and Mark White published in Social Psychological and Personality Science in 2018. They surveyed the same Americans in the final days of October 2016 and again in mid-November, just before and just after the presidential election. Among supporters of both candidates, the election significantly increased the perceived social acceptability of prejudice toward the specific groups the winning campaign had targeted, while perceived norms toward groups the campaign never mentioned barely moved. The authors concluded that a rising public tide of prejudiced rhetoric had lowered the standard against which people judged their own attitudes. Crandall’s laboratory has since reported a similar pattern after the 2024 election.
The lesson is not about any one party or politician. It is about mechanism. Leaders do not merely reflect norms; they set them, and they set them for the specific targets their rhetoric names. Jews were not among the groups in the 2016 study, but the mechanism does not care who the target is. A mayor who will not name a call for intifada for what it is, and who brands the Jewish state’s leader a perpetrator of genocide, has sent a signal about one particular group. Signals are heard, and they are heard most clearly by the people already inclined to act on them.
Fairness requires me to note that Mamdani kept the city’s Office to Combat Antisemitism and has condemned antisemitic vandalism in plain language. Words matter. But social psychologists Benoît Monin and Dale Miller described a phenomenon they called moral credentials, now often called moral licensing: in their experiments, people who first had an opportunity to establish themselves as unprejudiced were subsequently more willing to express views that could be read as prejudiced. The effect has been debated in later replication attempts, but the underlying intuition is one every clergyman and clinician recognizes. A visible good deed can quietly grant permission for later choices that cut the other way. A mayor’s commitments are measured in budgets, police deployments and appointments, not in posts on social media. On those measures, the Jewish community has been given little reason for confidence.
Should we be afraid?
Rebbe Nachman of Breslov taught that the whole world is a very narrow bridge, and the essential thing is not to make oneself afraid at all (Likutei Moharan II:48). Note the precision: he did not say the bridge is wide. He said the danger is real and fear must not be allowed to govern our steps.
Neuroscience has caught up with Rebbe Nachman, whose original Hebrew, shelo yitpached klal, uses a reflexive verb: not “do not be afraid” but “do not make yourself afraid.” Fear is the work of the amygdala, an ancient threat detector built for speed, not accuracy. The Yale neuroscientist Amy Arnsten has shown that even mild, uncontrollable stress rapidly impairs the prefrontal cortex, the seat of planning and judgment, while the same neurochemical surge strengthens the amygdala, setting up a vicious cycle. Frightened people and frightened communities think less clearly, generalize danger to everyone, and either freeze or flee. Yet imaging research offers something hopeful. In a 2007 functional MRI study published by Matthew Lieberman and colleagues at UCLA found that putting feelings into words, what they call affect labeling, diminished the amygdala’s response to distressing images and increased activity in the right ventrolateral prefrontal cortex. Naming the danger precisely quiets the alarm and returns the thinking brain to the helm. The Tanya of Rabbi Schneur Zalman of Liadi put it two centuries earlier (chapter 12), citing the Zohar’s Ra’aya Mehemna: by its innate nature, the mind rules over the heart.
So, no: we should not be afraid. Fear makes people hide their kippot and skip shul. Fear cedes the city. We should be alarmed, which is something different. Alarm is fear governed by the mind. It has a name, a target and a plan.
Criminologists have shown what such a plan can accomplish. In a landmark 1997 study published in Science, Robert Sampson, Stephen Raudenbush and Felton Earls surveyed nearly 8,800 residents of 343 Chicago neighborhoods. Neighborhoods with high collective efficacy, defined as social cohesion among neighbors combined with their willingness to intervene for the common good, suffered less violence, even after accounting for poverty, residential instability and prior violence. That is the Jewish answer too. Nehemiah’s builders rebuilt Jerusalem’s wall with a tool in one hand and a weapon in the other (Nehemiah 4:11). They did not stop building, and they did not pretend the threat away.
So, build and guard. Demand that City Hall publish a bed-by-bed accounting of where every seriously mentally ill detainee will go before another facility closes. Insist on real funding for forensic psychiatric beds, assertive community treatment and supportive housing. Insist that the NYPD Hate Crime Task Force be fully staffed, and that the mayor’s commitments on antisemitism be measured in dollars and officers. Document every incident. Organize. Vote.
Close Rikers? Yes, and the sooner the better. But build the parapet before you open the roof. Not on slogans, not on a press calendar, and not on the backs of the mentally ill or of New York’s Jews. Tzedek, tzedek tirdof: justice, pursued justly. Anything less is not justice. It is merely the relocation of injustice.
