Tamar Ziff

The politics of a genocide charge

In a recent interview with Haaretz, Chair of the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry into the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel Navi Pillay laid out her conditions for what, in her legal opinion, constitutes genocide. She is the main author of the September 2025 report which concludes that Israel is committing a genocide against Palestinians, which is considered key in the ongoing International Court of Justice case against Israel – submitted to the ICJ by South Africa on December 29, 2023 – on the matter.

In the global imagination, a genocide is the worst of all crimes, the “crime of crimes.” It is one of unimaginable inhumanity, cruelty, and barbarity – the Holocaust, the Rwandan genocide, the Bosnian genocide, the Yazidi genocide, and, as recently defined, the Rohingya genocide, all included systematic sexual violence, torture, and often features perpetrators going house to house to inflict sadistic acts on the target population. War – and the attendant war crimes and crimes against humanity that come with nearly all wars – is one thing, but genocide is another.

The central tenet of genocide, Pillay emphasizes, is the specific intent to eliminate a religious, national or ethnic group. According to her, the scale of killing is irrelevant: even one killing could become a genocide if the intent could be proven. This is somewhat counterintuitive. But let’s move forward. How does one infer this intent? Pillay says: “Many peoples want to be recognized for having experienced genocide… You have to understand that we don’t simply adopt a colloquial term. We look for the evidence, examine it, and see if the actions taken indicate intent. Then we look for that intent. Where is the evidence for that intent? We look at the orders given to the army, the speeches, the hateful words of the leaders. That’s also what we did in Rwanda.”

According to the 1948 Genocide Convention, the specific intent – dolus specialis – to destroy a specific group must be accompanied by at least one of five factors: 1) killing members of the group; 2) causing serious bodily or mental harm; 3) deliberately inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about physical destruction; 4) imposing measures intended to prevent births; and 5) forcibly transferring children of the group. So – “hateful words,” against a specific ethnic, religious, or national group – and one or more of the aforementioned factors. Okay.

The bar for determining specific intent is pretty high – it must be that the only reasonable inference from a state’s actions is the physical destruction of a national, religious, or ethnic group, rather than military victory or political suppression. So let’s list for a moment the concrete conditions that Pillay sets for reasonably inferring that Israel is committing, or committed, a genocide of Palestinians: 1) the leadership said dehumanizing things about them; 2) the IDF destroyed a significant amount of civil and medical infrastructure in a widespread bombing campaign; 3) there is damage to reproductive or fertility-related medical infrastructure, intended or not; and 4) there is a restriction on Palestinian access to essential supplies.

Is the only reasonable inference to these actions that Israel wants to destroy the Palestinian people as an ethnic group? Well, no. As myriad other commentators have noted, if Hamas didn’t exist, and hadn’t perpetrated the October 7 massacre after spending decades terrorizing Israelis and vowing to murder them, then perhaps a case could be made. With Hamas, the argument is moot. Could Israel have stopped the war sooner? Could it have made an earlier hostage deal with Hamas? Sure. These would probably have prevented a number of casualties and damage to buildings in the Gaza Strip. But the war in Gaza it was not premised on the intent to wipe out Palestinians as a people – it was premised on the intent to wipe out members of the terror group Hamas.

And what about Hamas? Did it not commit a genocide on October 7? Pillay’s most absurd claim in the interview is that the UN Commission found no “specific intent to destroy” Israel, or Jews, on the part of Hamas – that is, that Hamas’ frequent statements that its aim is to eliminate Israel and kill Jews, an aim codified in its founding 1988 Charter, could not be seen as such, whereas Israel’s wartime actions, and statements from its leadership, could.

Instead, the Hamas massacre on October 7 has been classified by the International Criminal Court as a “crime against humanity of extermination”. What is the main difference between this crime and genocide? Well – intent. Interestingly, committing a “crime against humanity of extermination” by definition involves a far higher scale of killing and brutality than genocide, which can include non-lethal methods of ethnic, national, or religious erasure. But, still, genocide is viewed as the more insidious crime, and automatically triggers the requirements of prevention and punishment by Convention signatories. It’s also, broadly speaking, a mark of intense shame – a stain on a country and its people.

But let’s go back to Pillay and the Genocide Convention. So – “the orders given to the army, the speeches, the hateful words of the leaders,” and then, killing, harm, destruction, birth control, or forceful transfer, with the only reasonable inference being the partial or total elimination of an ethnic, religious, or national group. Israel does not qualify, because there is this reality of Hamas as an active and, yeah, genocidal threat. But several other countries might.

First, there is Russia. Looking at the evidence – Russia’s systematic deportation and Russification of thousands of Ukrainian children; the widespread bombing of civilian and medical infrastructure, including the total destruction of certain cities; speeches by state leadership and on state media that Ukraine has no right to exist, and that it is a part of Russia – including the complete absence of any real threat posed by Ukraine to Russia, you know, it’s pretty damning. Groups like Genocide Watch and a handful of European national parliaments have passed resolutions recognizing the Russian war as genocide.

But the accusation is not broadly thrown around, for several reasons. First, fun fact, Russia cannot be tried for genocide at the ICJ because it signed the Genocide Convention with a reservation, preventing such a case to be brought against it. Second, a proven genocide triggers international action from other signatories, meaning countries would be forced to intervene in the Russo-Ukraine war, which many don’t want to do. Third, and most important: Russia is a powerful country that sits on the UN Security Council. It has incredible clout. The UN Commission on Ukraine chose to believe the Russian leadership’s stated objectives of territorial conquest and political subjugation, rather than, you know, elimination of an entire national group. (I wonder why.) The international consensus remains: Putin is a war criminal, he is responsible for crimes against humanity – but not genocide.

Then, you have China. Several countries, including the United States, Holland, and France, along with other independent bodies, have concluded that China is committing a genocide against its Uyghurs and other Turkic Muslim minorities in Xinjiang. The evidence – drops in Uyghur birth rates alongside reports of forced sterilizations; forced transfer of Uyghur children to to state-run boarding schools and orphanages, where they are brainwashed; mass arbitrary detention of an estimated one million or more people in internment camps, alongside documented torture, sexual violence, and forced labor; and leaked speeches by senior officials instructing authorities to “break their lineage” – including the absence of any real threat posed to China by the Uyghurs, yeah, that’s pretty damning.

But guess what? China can’t be tried at the ICJ either. Meanwhile, the UN has consistently avoided using the term genocide, sticking to “crimes against humanity.” Why? Well, similar to the Russian case – genocide means international intervention, and, moreover, it means souring the relationship to one of the West’s most important trade partners.

Then there’s Turkey. The 1915 Armenian genocide – in which over one million Armenians were massacred by Ottoman Turks – is still not recognized by the UN as a genocide, despite being acknowledged as such by over thirty countries, including, as of June 2026, Israel. Why does the UN refuse to grant Armenians a recognition of their unique historic suffering? Well, Turkey is a powerful country that many other countries don’t want to alienate. Furthermore, digging into pre-1948 “events” – as the genocide is referred to by the Turkish government – might be uncomfortable for other former colonial empires in Europe. In 2015, the European Court of Human Rights even ruled that it was not discriminatory for a Turkish citizen to deny the genocide, which he called “a great international lie” that lacked historical consensus.

These are the big ones. Then you have smaller cases. Take Syria. After former dictator Bashar al-Assad fled in December 2024, a provisional government was established under former Islamist militant Ahmed Al-Sharaa. In March 2025, members of the new Syrian armed forces killed some 1,400 Alawites in around 30 villages in response to an ambush by pro-Assad forces. Most of them were civilians, and the killings took the form of door-to-door executions, with soldiers asking residents, “Are you Alawi?”

A Human Rights Watch report detailed how “government-aligned armed groups and armed volunteers swept through Alawi-majority neighborhoods… leaving behind torched homes, piled bodies, mass graves…” A subsequent UN investigation found that there may have been war crimes and violations of international law by some individual members of certain factions of the security forces of the interim government. The UN report, important to note, detailed at length the ambush by pro-Assad forces that triggered the ensuing massacre, and emphasized in its report that both sides in the Syrian civil war committed serious war crimes and crimes against humanity. There it is again.

Individual Syrian commentators noted “genocidal rhetoric” against Alawites in Syria by official and semi-official media – but, you know, Syria is complicated. That’s what the UN report on the subsequent government-sponsored massacre of the Druze minority in Sweida concluded. Unsurprisingly, the UN Syria Commission did not call the deaths of 1,700 predominantly Druze civilians in July 2025 a genocide, even though that’s what some Druze leaders called it. Once again, we get “war crimes” and “crimes against humanity” caused by inter-community tension, and exacerbated – you can’t make this shit up – by “Israel’s military intervention [which] not only killed and maimed people but also contributed to instability.”

The further you go into the politics of what is considered a “genocide” and what is a “war crime” or “crime against humanity” – particularly by the UN – the more you realize that several countries will simply never be called genocidal, no matter what they do. Even ISIS was never formally convicted as having committed a genocide against the Yazidis, for political reasons: since neither Iraq nor Syria are members of the ICC, jurisdiction was only possible with United Nations approval. Russia and China vetoed this, and so there was no decision that “ISIS committed genocide.” Instead, ISIS perpetrators have been individually tried in national courts, most notably Germany.

There is an active legal and academic debate about whether “crimes against humanity” – including the crime of extermination – should trigger international intervention and an equal stigma to the charge of genocide. But this is a debate. The reality is that genocide remains a crime above all others; any country or individual found to have committed that crime will be uniquely branded as a villain.

It doesn’t matter that Pillay’s interpretation of “specified intent” is garbage, that her standards are prejudiced and her claims preposterous. Regardless of what the ICJ rules on Israel’s genocide case, in the court of popular opinion, according to the UN and several other prominent NGOS – Israel has already lost. No amount of proof or legal argumentation can contest a politically motivated charge.

About the Author
Tamar Ziff is a freelance journalist based in Tel Aviv. Previously, she worked on human rights and rule of law issues in the U.S. and Latin America.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.