Eliezer Simcha Weiss

The Status Quo Cannot Be Divided

When politicians negotiate to form a government, compromise is part of the process. They negotiate over budgets, ministries and priorities. That is how politics works. But not everything should be open to compromise. The foundations of Jewish life in Israel cannot be treated as bargaining chips.

For years, the phrase “preserving the status quo” has been used in discussions about religion and state. But what does it really mean today? Different parties interpret it differently, and the phrase has often become a convenient way of avoiding difficult questions. One issue may be protected while another is quietly pushed aside.

I write as a rabbi, but these are my personal views. I am not speaking for any institution or political party. Who forms a government is for the elected representatives and the public to decide. My concern is that, whoever forms the government, certain principles must not be abandoned.

Our responsibility is not limited to those who already observe Torah and mitzvot. Protecting yeshivot and religious institutions is important, but we must also think about every Jewish child growing up in Israel. Children in the general school system deserve to learn Torah, Tanakh and the history of their own people. A Jewish child should not grow up in the Land of Israel without knowing the heritage that has sustained our people for generations. This is a responsibility we owe to the entire Jewish people.

The question of who is a Jew is just as important. It is not simply a matter of paperwork or legal definitions. It affects the unity of our people and our future. The distinction between eligibility under the Law of Return and Halachic Jewish status must remain clear. Conversion must be guided by Halacha.

If we abandon a common Halachic standard, we risk creating divisions that may become very difficult to repair. In the future, this could affect the ability of Jews to marry one another according to Halacha. This is not a concern affecting one community alone. It is a concern for the entire Jewish people.

Shabbat, kashrut, and marriage and divorce according to Halacha are also not matters to be dealt with only when coalition negotiations demand it. Shabbat in the public sphere, the standards of kashrut and the Halachic framework of marriage and divorce are part of the Jewish character of life in Israel. They should not be seen as privileges belonging to one group. They affect all of us.

Torah study must not be treated simply as another budgetary issue or as a temporary solution to a political problem. Throughout our history, Torah has kept the Jewish people alive. Those who dedicate their lives to learning Torah are not merely another interest group seeking government support. Any discussion of their place in Israeli society must begin with a genuine recognition of the importance of Torah to the Jewish people.

Israel must also remain clearly the nation-state of the Jewish people. The civil rights of every citizen, Jewish and non-Jewish alike, must be protected. There is no contradiction between respecting the rights of all citizens and maintaining the Jewish identity of the state. Israel’s national character and the Jewish people’s right to a national home in their own Land must not be weakened.

These principles are not directed against any political party. They must apply equally to every government. We cannot protect one aspect of Jewish life while allowing another to be compromised. Shabbat, Torah education, kashrut, Halachic conversion, marriage and the Jewish character of the state are not separate issues to be traded against one another.

The challenge is not simply to preserve what is called the status quo. It is to ensure that the foundations of Jewish life in Israel are not weakened one by one, each compromise justified by the political needs of the moment.

The status quo cannot be divided. Our responsibility is to the Torah, to the Jewish people, to the Jewish character of the Land of Israel and to the generations that will follow us.

–

The author is a member of the Council of the Chief Rabbinate of Israel. The views expressed here are his personal views.

About the Author
Rabbi Eliezer Simcha Weiss made aliyah from Manchester in 1985, where he had served as a rabbi, qualified as a lawyer, and was president of the Zionist Central Council. For over 30 years, he served as the rabbi of Kfar Haroeh and Emek Hefer, and, following his retirement, was elected to the Chief Rabbinate Council. He serves on numerous committees, including the Interreligious Committee for Relations with the Vatican, representing the Chief Rabbinate on various occasions. He is currently the practicing rabbi of Bnei Brak and Givat Shmuel.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.