Nima Gholam Ali Pour

The West Must Not Miss Iran’s Mandela Moment

Since protests erupted in Iran in late December, a broad movement within the Iranian diaspora has rallied behind Crown Prince Reza Pahlavi. He has presented a detailed plan for guiding Iran through a transitional government toward a democratic political system.

No opposition movement that emerges organically and remains decentralized will be free of shortcomings. Iran’s intelligence services also have a long history of infiltrating opposition groups abroad. Some of the movement’s divisions and failures may therefore have been created or exacerbated by agents of the Islamic Republic.

Even so, it is striking that so few Western governments have offered meaningful support for Pahlavi’s agenda. The Iranian regime has spent decades engaging in hostile activities against Western countries, including espionage, terrorist plots, cyberattacks, hostage diplomacy and transnational repression.

Western governments have a clear interest in supporting a political force that seeks to replace this regime with one that respects democracy and human rights. Such a transition would reduce the threat Iran poses to the West and make greater stability in the Middle East far more likely.

This is Iran’s Mandela moment. A regime that has brutalized the Iranian people is not being met with demands for revenge or another dictatorship, but with demands for democracy and freedom. At the same time, a leader has emerged whose stated ambition is to oversee a peaceful transition toward democratic rule. There is no guarantee that this moment—or its political momentum—will return.

Iran is a dictatorship, making it difficult to know what people inside the country truly believe. Yet available evidence cannot simply be dismissed. Four years ago, Pahlavi enjoyed the strongest support of any named political figure among respondents inside Iran. More recent polling indicates that this support has endured even after the war began.

Opinion polls are not a substitute for an electoral mandate. But in an Islamist dictatorship where no free national election is planned, they are among the closest available measures of one.

There are many arguments against Pahlavi, but many of these arguments are also remarkably weak. One recurring criticism concerns his father’s rule. The irony is that Mohammad Reza Shah was repeatedly praised by Western leaders during his rule. From Eisenhower to Carter, six consecutive American presidents—Republicans and Democrats alike—publicly credited him with modernizing Iran, preserving its independence and promoting regional stability.

There were legitimate criticisms of the Shah’s authoritarian rule. But much of the one-dimensional narrative that now dominates the discussion took shape after the 1979 revolution. Why remain so focused on relitigating the past while Iranians today are oppressed by a regime committing atrocities that cannot be excused by pointing to the abuses of the Shah’s era?

That criticism also fails because Crown Prince Reza Pahlavi is not seeking to restore the system that fell in 1979. He has consistently said that Iranians must determine their future system of government through a referendum. When I read his book Winds of Change 24 years ago, he was making the same argument he makes today.

Meanwhile, the current regime is disrupting shipping through the Strait of Hormuz and destabilizing both the region and the global economy. Even if this crisis is resolved, the underlying threat will remain. The regime could move closer to acquiring nuclear weapons, sponsor a major terrorist attack in Europe or create another regional crisis to justify repression at home. Israel and Gulf states, including Saudi Arabia—which have been attacked by Iran directly and through its proxies—cannot and will not accept a nuclear-armed Iran.

Pahlavi therefore represents not only a historic opportunity for Iranians, but also an opportunity to transform the world’s relationship with Iran. An Iran that cooperates with other nations instead of attacking its neighbors and sponsoring terrorism would fundamentally change the Middle East for the better.

Western governments should hold more high-level meetings with Pahlavi, recognize him as a key democratic partner and establish an international contact group for Iran’s democratic transition. Supporting him does not mean allowing the West to choose Iran’s next ruler or decide between a republic and a monarchy. It means giving Iranians a genuine opportunity to choose freely.

Supporting Pahlavi today does not mean crowning a king. It means giving a democratic transition a fighting chance.

History will not ask whether Crown Prince Reza Pahlavi was flawless. It will ask whether the world’s democracies recognized a rare opening for freedom—or stood by and watched it close.

Iran’s future belongs to the Iranian people. But the moment to stand with them is now.

About the Author
Nima Gholam Ali Pour is a Swedish political commentator and former member of the Swedish Parliament. He holds a master’s degree in International Migration and Ethnic Relations and writes primarily about Iran, democracy, and international affairs.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.