Sophie Bulkin

When Antisemitism Becomes Discretionary

I grew up understanding that being Jewish was not always something to make visible. My parents were raised in the former Soviet Union, where Jewish life existed mostly in private. Religion was practiced at home, spoken about carefully, and kept out of public view.

That sensibility shaped how they raised me. It was not framed as fear. It showed up as awareness, knowing when attention could become unsafe. For a long time, I understood that history to be something that belonged more to my parents’ past than to my own life.

When Zohran Mamdani moved to revoke the IHRA definition of antisemitism, I recognized the pattern. He was able to do so through policy discretion rather than legislation, a reminder of how easily protections can be undone.

I had seen before what happens when institutions are left without clear standards after harm occurs.

A gunman opened fire at my synagogue in Poway. The violence was undeniable. What followed was quieter. As the shock faded, attention shifted toward interpretation. Language mattered. Motivation mattered. Accountability moved slowly.

Years later, I saw the same pattern at UC Berkeley. Antisemitism on campus rarely appeared as explicit slurs. It surfaced during protests, in chants calling to globalize the intifada. It appeared in classrooms, where Jewish students were expected to defend their existence as a political position. When my cousin was choked by a protester for attending an event where an Israeli soldier was speaking, she was met with hesitation, not justice. Administrators debated intent. Discipline stalled. Without clear standards, responsibility thinned out.

This is where the IHRA definition mattered. Not because it solved antisemitism, but because it constrained discretion. It gave institutions a shared reference point when antisemitism did not look obvious or convenient to address. It made it harder to treat uncertainty as a reason to do nothing.

The IHRA definition, developed by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance, is not a law. It does not criminalize speech or prohibit criticism of Israel. It functions as guidance, used by governments, universities, and civil rights bodies when intent and impact are disputed. Its value lies in consistency. It limits how morality and  standards can shift from one administration to the next.

Removing that definition does not expand free expression. It expands discretion. When standards can be withdrawn through executive or administrative action, without legislative debate and without replacement, protection becomes fragile. Fragile protections do not survive changes in leadership.

This is not hypothetical. Policy decisions like this one do not remain isolated. Universities watch what elected officials do. Agencies take cues. When antisemitism is treated as too controversial to define, others follow. What begins as a choice becomes a norm.

I recognize the concern that the IHRA definition can be misused. Any framework can be. But misuse calls for refinement, not erasure. Other civil rights protections are strengthened through clearer guidance and statutory grounding. Antisemitism should not be treated differently.

This pattern is familiar to my family. In the places my parents grew up, antisemitism was rarely addressed directly. It was softened, reframed, or ignored. That did not make anyone safer. It allowed harm to persist until it could no longer be denied.

The danger of removing the IHRA definition is not only what it does now, but what it signals: that recognition of antisemitism can be granted or withdrawn at will, and that Jewish safety depends on who holds office.

That should be unacceptable. Civil rights protections are not supposed to fluctuate with elections. They exist precisely to constrain the discretion of whoever is in power. When protections against antisemitism exist only at the discretion of elected officials, they will shift with politics. That is the precedent being set.

Recognition of antisemitism must be embedded in law. Statutory protection is the only way to ensure that Jewish communities are not left exposed every time power changes hands.

About the Author
My name is Sophie Bulkin and I am a Jewish student interested in law and politics. My work examines antisemitism, civil rights, and the role of legal standards in protecting vulnerable communities.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.