When Principles Become Negotiable: A Challenge to Both Parties
In an October 2024 conversation with Bari Weiss, Brianna Wu, a longtime progressive activist, transgender advocate and former Democratic congressional candidate, described a political movement she increasingly struggled to recognize. She still believed in the progressive principles that brought her into politics, however, what troubled her, was the willingness of people she considered as allies to abandon those principles when Israel entered the conversation. Sound familiar? It certainly hit home for me.
Her argument then and still today invites a disturbing question: how does a movement committed to universal healthcare and equal rights produce voices willing to excuse Hamas and call for an annihilation of the Jewish people?
America prepares to welcome a new Congress. Israel “played” its part as a campaign issue, a major one in some races, or even as the reason one party lost to the other to quote both the President and Vice President.
I write these words as a person who still believes that he has a stake in the health of American democracy and the relationship between the two countries I call home. I feel comfortable making this claim because the relationship between both countries requires that both sustain a healthy democracy. From that perspective, what worries me most is how readily political movements in the United States make their principles negotiable when applying them becomes uncomfortable.
In Wu’s telling, mainstream progressives allowed their causes to become entangled with radical activists more interested in tearing down institutions than improving people’s lives. I share this claim. Shared opposition to political enemies gradually overshadowed commitments to healthcare, equality, and practical reform, while challenging an ally’s extremism increasingly meant risking exclusion from the movement.
Her disillusionment over the “treatment” Israel received was therefore part of a broader reckoning with a political culture in which compassion was becoming conditional and solidarity demanded conformity. Her account offers a warning: a movement can continue speaking the language of inclusion while increasingly defining itself through the people it excludes and the enemies it condemns.
Questioning the other side of the American political divide she asked: How does a movement that champions constitutional government, individual freedom and personal responsibility accommodate attacks on democratic institutions and make excuses for extremists within its own ranks? In this respect just like on the progressive side, she knows a thing or two about conservatism. She grew up in a very conservative Christian Republican home.
So here is the next question: How could a party that campaigns on law and order reckon with President Trump’s sweeping January 2025 clemency for January 6 offenses? And next, how is that same party confronting antisemitism rising in their own ranks?
When Tucker Carlson hosted Nick Fuentes in October 2025, the resulting controversy reached deep into conservative institutions. Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts initially defended Carlson and resisted calls to exclude Fuentes. He subsequently issued an explicit condemnation of Fuentes’s antisemitism and Holocaust denial. Conservatives who challenged the initial response demonstrated why movements need people willing to confront their own side.
That means that a Jew living in Michigan does not become a legitimate target because Israel has a powerful army. And that rule applies to the extremes that both Democrats and Republicans refer to as the “big tent.”
The reaction to October 7 exposed a major flaw in America. Do you remember the statement issued that day by Harvard’s Palestine Solidarity Committee, initially co-signed by thirty-three other student organizations, which assigned Israel responsibility for all the unfolding violence?
That statement did not speak for all progressives or for the Democratic Party. It did illustrate a dangerous habit: deciding who is guilty before examining what they have done.
Understanding inequalities of power is essential to understanding conflict. But when the distinction between powerful and powerless replaces every other moral consideration, an analysis becomes an excuse. The weaker actor can be granted permission to commit atrocities, while the stronger population is denied the right to be mourned.
A progressive movement should recognize the contradiction immediately. Commitment to women’s equality, religious freedom and minority rights ought to inform its judgment of Hamas. Here is what progressives really need to focus on. Calling for Palestinian freedom should include freedom from armed authoritarian movements that claim ownership of the Palestinian cause.
There is no contradiction between supporting Palestinian self-determination and condemning Hamas without qualification. Nor is there a contradiction between defending Israel’s existence and criticizing an Israeli government. A politics confident in its principles should be able to hold these positions together.
Republicans should be equally willing to examine their own exceptions.
Jewish safety cannot depend on the party affiliation of the person threatening it. Condemning antisemitism on campus while accommodating it among influential conservatives is an abandonment of principle. So is condemning it on the far right while explaining it away among political allies on the left.
These failures are not interchangeable. A student organization, a broadcaster and a president exercise profoundly distinct kinds of power. The parties have different histories, policies and responsibilities but what connects these examples is the temptation to protect an ally at the expense of a stated belief.
That temptation also threatens the relationship between America and Israel.
For years, many Israelis have treated Republican support as a permanent asset and Democratic criticism as an increasingly permanent liability. This encourages complacency on one side and withdrawal on the other.
Americans are entitled to question foreign assistance, oppose military intervention and scrutinize Israeli policy. Israelis should engage those arguments; however, engagement becomes harder when a country and its people are reduced to symbols in someone else’s domestic political struggle.
We Israelis also bear responsibility for resisting that reduction. We cannot build a durable relationship with America around a single president, party or ideological constituency. We need Americans to encounter the breadth of Israeli society: its disagreements, democratic aspirations, community organizations, scientific work and everyday cooperation across religious and ethnic boundaries. We must also be willing to discuss honestly the decisions that undermine trust.
The incoming Congress offers an opportunity to practice that seriousness.
Democrats could defend Palestinian rights if they chose to, while rejecting efforts to make hostility toward Israel a test of progressive belonging. Republicans and Democrats should confront antisemitism within their own political circles and uphold constitutional accountability when it inconveniences their leaders. Both should distinguish the long-term interests of peoples from the immediate preferences of governments.
Members of Congress should remember that governing requires judgment independent of the loudest voices within their coalitions.
Wu’s challenge matters because movements rarely announce that they have abandoned their values. They retain the language, equality remains in the platform, and freedom remains in the speech. The exceptions accumulate until the principle no longer governs anyone’s conduct.
The new Congress should begin by refusing those exceptions. Its members will demonstrate what they believe when defending it costs them applause from their own side.

