Who Wants to Replace Israel as America’s Top Ally?
On the American Right, Tucker Carlson has repeatedly portrayed Israel as a burden on American foreign policy, while self-proclaimed Marxist and Mao Zedong apologist streamer Hasan Piker, who notoriously declared that America deserved the September 11 terrorist attacks, has made slander against Israel a prominent feature of his commentary.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has warned about the “Woke Right” and its demonization of Israel, while mainstream factions of the American Left routinely denounce the world’s only Jewish state as an apartheid regime. However, the growing hostility toward Israel is hardly a coincidence, nor is it exclusively about the aftermath of October 7th.
It reflects a broader geopolitical struggle in which regional powers in the Middle East employ hybrid warfare, exploiting anti-Israel propaganda and the Palestinian issue to weaken Israel’s relationship with Washington and ultimately displace it as America’s closest ally in the Middle East.
Firstly, the competition for American influence is increasingly evident in Syria, where Turkey and Israel pursue conflicting strategic objectives. Following Bashar al-Assad’s overthrow in December 2024, Ankara emerged as a principal beneficiary of Syria’s political transformation, strengthening its relationship with Ahmed al-Sharaa’s government.
American withdrawal from Syria has further increased Turkey’s opportunities to shape Syria’s future. Ankara favors a unitary Syrian state and opposes Kurdish independence, while Israel remains concerned about al-Sharaa’s Islamist background, supports the idea of a Kurdish state, and seeks to secure the Golan Heights, which it annexed in 1981.
Syria’s new president, Ahmed al-Shaara led the Nusra Front, an offshoot of the US designated terrorist organization Al Qaeda in Syria. Al Qaeda was responsible for the 9/11 terror attacks. So, Israel’s concerns are not based on hypotheticals but on concrete evidence of the new Islamist path of Syria, after ousting tyrant Bashar al Assad in December of 2024.
However, Turkey’s confrontation with Israel extends beyond Syria. President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has repeatedly accused Israel of committing genocide in Gaza, while maintaining political relations with Hamas.
Meanwhile, Washington approved a $23 billion F-16 package for Turkey in 2024, demonstrating Ankara’s continued importance to American security policy. Turkey’s role as a NATO member, combined with its increasingly hostile rhetoric toward Israel, raises questions about how Ankara seeks to reshape America’s regional priorities. So does Qatar.
Qatar maintains extensive economic relationships with Washington and has established itself as an important diplomatic intermediary. Yet Qatar’s growing strategic importance coincides with its longstanding relationship with Hamas, whose political leadership it has hosted since 2012.
Former Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett has rightfully warned about the creation of a new Sunni axis led by Turkey and Qatar seeking to encircle Israel. He called Turkey, the “new Iran”. Turkey is not the “new Iran” and it will never be one, but it has certainly taken steps to fill the power vacuum in the Middle East if and when the Iranian regime falls.
Secondly, the Palestinian issue has become an instrument of hybrid warfare against Israel and the American-led regional order. Iran has spent decades financing, arming, and training terrorist militias the likes of Hamas in Gaza, Hezbollah in Lebanon, and the Houthis in Yemen.
These organizations constitute important elements of Tehran’s so-called “Axis of Resistance”, employing terrorism, missile attacks, and other forms of asymmetric warfare to challenge Israel and American interests throughout the region.
The Muslim Brotherhood, whose Palestinian branch gave rise to Hamas, has similarly incorporated Palestine into its broader Islamist political agenda. Qatar’s hosting of Hamas’s leadership demonstrates how the Palestinian issue intersects with the ambitions of American partners.
Hybrid warfare is not unique to the Middle East. China has increasingly employed information operations to exploit divisions within American society, while research has documented networks associated with CCP-linked businessmen that support socialist and communist-oriented organizations involved in anti-American and pro-Palestinian activism.
Qatar on its end has provided billions of dollars in gifts and contracts to American universities, raising concerns about foreign influence over higher education. These allegations warrant scrutiny following the anti-Israel protests that spread across American universities after October 7, 2023.
The media offers another avenue for political influence. Far-left Turkish American commentator Hasan Piker and his Turkish-born uncle, founder of the progressive network The Young Turks Cenk Uygur, have become prominent critics of Israel, exemplifying the current anti-Israel sentiment in Turkey. In the meantime, far-right and anti-Israel political commentator Candace Owens has faced repeated accusations of receiving Qatari financial support.
During the December 2025 Doha Forum, Tucker Carlson interviewed Qatari Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani, providing Doha’s leadership with an opportunity to whitewash its relationship with Hamas and challenge Israel before an influential American conservative audience.
Critics may argue that opposition to Israel reflects legitimate disagreements over Gaza rather than foreign propaganda. However, legitimate political disagreements and foreign influence operations are not mutually exclusive.
As Chinese and Russian hybrid warfare demonstrate, foreign powers, including China, Russia, Qatar or the Muslim Brotherhood, can exploit existing political divisions through propaganda and misinformation. The geopolitical objective of Qatar, Turkey and the Muslim Brotherhood is the replacement of Israel as America’s principal ally in the Middle East.
For decades, Israel has remained America’s closest ally in the Middle East because of its military capabilities, intelligence cooperation, and shared security interests. Yet the competition unfolding in Syria, the exploitation of the Palestinian issue, and foreign influence in American political discourse demonstrate that hybrid warfare can threaten strategic alliances without a conventional military confrontation. The goal of such hybrid warfare is the replacement of Israel as America’s closest ally in the Middle East.
