Ed Moss
Former journalist, now a grumpy old man

Why do Britain’s public institutions need outsiders to challenge their own employees?

Author-generated image

Who polices the guardians? Why do Britain’s public institutions need outsiders to challenge their own employees?

If Britain’s universities, schools, NHS trusts, government departments, and even the Houses of Parliament cannot police their own publicly stated standards of conduct, what, precisely, are their equality and diversity departments there to do? Make tea?

There are bucketfuls of policies, procedures, equality officers, human resources departments and, in many cases, entire teams dedicated to promoting inclusion in Britain’s public institutions. They are quite adept, all too often after the fact, at publishing statements condemning racism, discrimination and intolerance when the past practices of current employees come to light.

Why is it then that external organisations such as UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI) appear so often to have to challenge conduct involving antisemitism within institutions that should be perfectly capable of dealing with it themselves? The London School of Economics (LSE) recently removed a Muslim chaplain from her voluntary role. His antisemitic social media posts had been unearthed by UKLFI, not by the HR, Diversity and Inclusion staff of the academic institution itself, but by an alert through the research of an external body.

The Campaign Against Antisemitism (CAA) in the UK has had to draft a detailed report about action needed to combat antisemitism in medicine. Why should it have to? Medical treatment is the right of every single resident in the UK. Medical people are brilliant and very well-trained at what they do. But if they can’t manage their own morals and do the right thing from the outset, are they really all that brilliant?

This is not an argument about religion, ethnicity or political affiliation. Being Muslim, Jewish, Christian or atheist is entirely irrelevant if somebody is behaving in an unacceptable manner at work. The issue is all about individual conduct, institutional responsibility and that there is a consistent application of standards.

Universities, schools, NHS trusts and government departments all employ people who have major responsibilities towards their colleagues, students, patients and the public. Those responsibilities don’t just disappear in a plume of mist when an employee expresses political opinions, becomes involved in campaigning or uses social media to air their personal views. HR seniors are not paid a mere minimum wage. They are supposedly highly-trained professionals in a specific field.

Freedom of expression is important, and criticism of Israel, support for Palestinian rights and sometimes, but sadly not very often when you examine the Green Party, some councils, universities and unions in the UK, opposition to Zionism, are not always automatically antisemitic. Labelling something as “political expression” does not allow its automatic exclusion from professional standards or equality legislation. That is, unless you work in politics itself, but then equally, it should not be an excuse for questionable, partisan behaviour.

The distinction should not be that difficult to understand. The Equality Act 2010 defines behaviour for public authority workers through its Public Sector Equality Duty. This includes having a proactive regard to eliminating discrimination and harassment and fostering good relations between all different groups.

So why, when allegations of antisemitism arise, does the affected complainant, themselves or with the help of an external organisation, have to respond to the shallow words from the organisation that state “we take racism and antisemitism very seriously”, but in reality does nothing? Really? They are not a broadband supplier that “takes it very seriously” for the customer who had difficulty leaving and transgresses once more when a customer attempts to leave again but can’t get past the AI customer service chatbot.

Why don’t these organisations utilise their expensive HR, diversity and inclusion teams and take proactive and preventative measures in the first place? It can initially be as basic as putting the name of a prospective candidate into an internet search engine.

Consider the position of a Jewish student, teacher, NHS employee or civil servant who believes they have experienced antisemitic conduct. An employee should be able to approach their employer with confidence that the complaint will be examined impartially, seriously and promptly. The employee should not have to become amateur investigators, assemble evidence, research employment policies and seek outside assistance simply to persuade their employer or institution to take notice of them. IF they have to, that is most certainly a red flag against the employer.

An institution should not need an external legal organisation to explain that its own equality policies apply to antisemitism just as they apply them to other forms of racism and bigotry in the workplace. But we regularly witness organisations such as the UN, the BBC and the Green Party having to be reminded repeatedly.

External organisations do take complaints they receive about employers and others very seriously. Any complaints cannot be facile and simply complaints for complaints’ sake. They have to be evidence-based; any investigation as a result must be fair, and legitimate political expression, if allowed, must not be stopped. The external organisations themselves must not be beyond scrutiny. But that does not mean the workplace institutions concerned are absolved from any responsibility. Surely the involvement of an external organisation should ring loud alarm bells and raise the question of why an employee needed to seek external intervention in the first place.

There is also a very serious concern about consistency. Would the same institution respond as slowly if the alleged target of discrimination belonged to another religious or ethnic group? Would the same standards apply if the individual complained about held a senior position, enjoyed considerable influence or was politically well connected? These are questions that institutional leaders should be prepared to answer.

It is not sufficient to have a zero-tolerance policy on paper alone, sitting there and looking very pretty and correct. It has to mean something in practice. Any organisation that regularly claims to condemn antisemitism, but fails to address credible allegations within, has a real credibility problem. And this is not about giving Jewish people preferential treatment. Quite the opposite. It is that the same standards of behaviour, accountability and protection are there and applied to everyone.

The responsibility also extends to professional regulators and governing bodies. Britain’s public institutions should not be relying on outsiders to identify problems that their own management structures are supposed to prevent, investigate and resolve. It’s not just fancy working on a website or in a glossy HR document.

It’s not about how many complaints UKLFI, CAA or other organisations have been asked to pursue. It’s more about how many would never have needed to be pursued in the first place had the institutions concerned done their jobs properly.

So who polices the guardians? Why should they have to be told how to do the job they have been employed at considerable expense to do, and supposedly have had training and expertise in? Remember, HR, diversity and inclusion teams do not generate profit for an organisation and, as such, are a fixed business expense, so they have almost a business morality to work hard at what they do. If those entrusted with upholding equality cannot demonstrate that they apply it consistently, who then is holding them accountable?

Who polices our public institutions?

Why should organisations such as UK Lawyers for Israel (UKLFI) continually have to intervene to challenge alleged antisemitism within Britain’s universities, schools, NHS trusts and government departments?

These institutions have HR departments, equality officers, professional codes and, supposedly, so they claim, robust anti-discrimination policies. Surely identifying and addressing racism within their own organisations is their responsibility, not an outside organisation’s job?

A Jewish student, employee or member of the public should not have to seek external assistance simply to persuade an institution to investigate a credible complaint, whether current or historical.

This is not about religion or political opinion. Being Muslim, Jewish, Christian or atheist is immaterial. Criticism of Israel is not automatically antisemitic, but neither should political expression provide immunity from professional standards or discriminatory conduct. The Equality Act’s obligations do not come with religious or political exemptions.

Nor should this be a question of preferential treatment for one community. The same standards must apply to everybody, irrespective of their background, seniority or influence.

The question we really need to be asking institutional leaders is why their own organisations apparently need constant reminders to do their jobs.

If public institutions cannot police their own standards, who is policing them?

About the Author
Edward Moss is a retired journalist and a volunteer Israel and anti-antisemitism advocate living in the North West of England. He was editor of UK Ports Magazine prior to his retirement and has edited several business magazines during his career.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.