Gil Mildar
"Violence can be justifiable, but it will never be legitimate." — Hannah Arendt

The Fate of Israel

Benjamin Netanyahu should have stepped down long before last week. In nearly 19 years as Prime Minister, almost four of them at the head of this government, he has been on trial for bribery, fraud, and breach of trust, tried to subordinate the courts to his coalition, presided over the worst day in the country’s history without accepting a state commission of inquiry, moved to fire both the head of the Shin Bet and the Attorney General, and handed ministries to the heirs of Kach. The latest item on the list has a name.

He is Sayaf Abu Riash, a physician from Rahat. On October 27th, Netanyahu paraded him and two other Ra’am activists, Ibrahim al-Gharibi and Hussein Masoudin, before the country as proof that the Arabs were trying to steal the election, and all three have since been released without charges. Police entered Abu Riash’s home without a warrant before dawn on Election Day, found nothing, and held him for six days. The man accused of stealing the election lost his own vote.

Netanyahu’s office said that his chief of staff, Ido Norden, had passed the tip to the police “as expected of a law-abiding citizen.” Law-abiding is not the word I would use for a man who phoned the Police Commissioner’s office on the eve of an election with an unproved accusation against Arab activists, a call the Attorney General is now examining as possibly part of a planned effort to delegitimize the vote. Judge Eran Tzabari had already found a better use for the phrase. On November 1st, he ordered the doctor released without conditions and described him as a law-abiding citizen leading an ordinary life. So Israel has two law-abiding citizens, the one who accuses and the one who goes to jail. Netanyahu keeps telling us that “the fate of Israel hangs in the balance.” He is right, though not in the way he means, because it hangs on whether our law treats these two men alike.

Gadi Eisenkot said last Sunday that Netanyahu cannot remain at the head of the government “for a minute longer.” I would only add that the minute ran out long ago. The head of the police Investigations and Intelligence Division conceded that the tip had come from the Prime Minister’s Office and that this did not sound good, an assessment that errs on the side of modesty. Netanyahu has not withdrawn his claim that the election was stolen, a claim that even the Shin Bet could not substantiate, though the Shin Bet is run by David Zini, a man Netanyahu handpicked.

On Saturday night, Likud published what it calls its conditions for unity. One clause demands an end to all incitement against Netanyahu. Another bars Eisenkot from governing with the parties Likud accuses of supporting terrorism, which is to say with nineteen Knesset members and with the Arab fifth of the country that they represent. One pictures the drafters at party headquarters finishing the clause against name-calling, stretching their legs, and moving on to the clause that brands those nineteen as supporters of terror. I call that clause what it is, racism on party letterhead, and Eisenkot should not sign it.

To be sure, when President Herzog asked Mansour Abbas on November 5th whether Hamas was a terrorist organization, Abbas declined to say so, citing fears for himself and his family. A partner in government owes the country that word. On the same day, though, Abbas told Herzog that Ra’am supported disarming Hamas, an odd position for a supporter of terror, and he has since been reported to have agreed in principle to say it. The Arab citizens who voted for Ra’am and the Joint List are as Israeli as I am. A government that relied on their votes would be no concession to them, and it would be the plainest answer we could give to the charge that Israel is a democracy only for its Jews, a charge our diplomats have spent years rebutting.

The Harvard professors Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt list four warning signs of authoritarian behavior and write that a politician who meets even one is cause for concern. Netanyahu already shows three, in the stolen-election claim, in the terror label pinned on his opponents, and in the warrantless raids on opposition activists before dawn on Election Day, on a tip that came through his office. The fourth is tolerating violence, and Eisenkot warned on Friday that the road from Netanyahu’s words to violence could be very short. The Hebrew University’s Avishai Margalit defined a decent society as one whose institutions do not humiliate the people under their authority. By that measure we failed Sayaf Abu Riash once, at his door, and Likud wants Eisenkot to help us fail him again.

The government tried to fire Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara in August of last year and failed. In July, the outgoing Knesset passed a law that will strip her opinions of their binding force on January 1st and give the coalition the power to appoint and dismiss whoever holds the office. Last week, she asked the Police Commissioner to suspend the review the police had opened into their own officers’ behavior on Election Day, citing a possible conflict of interest, and in doing so showed why the government wants her disarmed. If the law takes effect, a man on trial for bribery, fraud, and breach of trust will have a hand in appointing and dismissing the official who prosecutes him. The Knesset has approved the repeal in a preliminary reading and must finish before January, because an independent Attorney General is the line between a majority and a regime.

Consider what else happens if he stays. If Eisenkot fails by December 6th, or by the 20th with an extension, we may be sent back to the polls under a caretaker who controls the police that raided a home in Rahat, a Shin Bet run by his own appointee, and, if that law stands, an Attorney General he can fire. The next election would then be run by the man whose office sent the police after Arab activists on the eve of the last one. He also keeps the power to take us deeper into the war we have lived under since the end of February, in which Tehran fired missiles and drones at two American bases in Bahrain only last night. Avigdor Liberman said on Friday that there is no security justification for striking Iran now and that, if Netanyahu decides to strike, the decision will be politically motivated. Liberman would hardly pass for a pacifist. None of this requires a coup, only that Netanyahu remain where he is for a few more weeks.

Today the teams of Yashar and Likud begin the marathon of talks that Eisenkot proposed. I write as a Zionist who supports this country in spite of the people now governing it. I ask Eisenkot to reject the clause and, if Likud makes it the price of unity, to put the government that the voters made possible to a Knesset vote by December 6th, with the support or the abstention of the Arab parties. Liberman has promised to vote against such a government, and Bennett is expected to follow. They will then have to explain why they would rather leave the fate of Israel in the hands of the man whose office made that phone call.

About the Author
As a Brazilian, Jewish, and humanist writer, I carry a cultural mosaic that shapes my perspective and conduct. Nine years ago, I made the pivotal decision to immigrate to Israel, a journey bridging my ancestral roots with an active role in the ongoing dialogue between past, present, and future. My Latin American heritage and life in Israel have cemented an unwavering commitment to diversity, inclusion, and social justice. In my writing, I explore themes of authoritarianism, memory, and resistance, seeking not merely to reflect on the arc of history, but to effectively contribute to building a more equitable tomorrow. My work is an invitation to reflection and action, striving, above all borders, to promote human dignity.
Related Topics
Related Posts
Sign in or Register
Please use the following structure: example@domain.com
Or Continue with
By registering you agree to the terms and conditions
Register to continue
Or Continue with
Log in to continue
Sign in or Register
Or Continue with
check your email
Check your email
We sent an email to you at .
It has a link that will sign you in.