The Message I’m Sending Now About ‘Zios in the Back’
In the aftermath of October 7, I lost the vast majority of my Muslim friends. At first, I wondered if those friendships had been more superficial than I’d realized. Looking back, I still believe some of them ran deep. But I wonder if they only wanted a small part of me, the part they could understand as an American Jew at a comfortable distance from Israel. Then I told them where I was.
I’d spent years in Jewish-Muslim dialogue. In those gatherings, I talked about my family, my faith, and what Israel meant to me. I listened when people told me things that were hard to hear, and I trusted that they would do the same for me. It was easy to believe we’d built friendships when getting along asked so little of us. I thought those years of showing up for one another would count for something when it got hard.
One by one, they reached out to ask “how my family was doing.” When I told them I was in Israel, too, something almost tangible shifted. The conversation turned to Palestinians in Gaza. In Israel, we were still counting the dead, trying to learn who was missing, and bracing for what might come next. I remember how disorienting it was to feel there was suddenly so little room for my answer. I wanted someone who knew me to ask what it was like to be there. What hurt was how quickly people I’d trusted stopped asking, and how easy it seemed for them to walk away from something I’d given so much of myself to.
There was one friendship in particular I thought was ironclad. I unfollowed her, though we remained Facebook friends. Every now and then I’d peek at her page and see the milestones and accomplishments she shared. I always wanted to reach out. I never did. Then, on November 4, she posted a photo of herself with Senator-elect El-Sayed. “MEET YOUR FIRST MUSLIM SENATOR, AMERICA!” she wrote in the caption. Across the photo itself, with celebratory emojis, she’d added, “One more time for MAGA Zios in the back.”
Zios. It felt like a punch in the gut. I thought about commenting, sending her a WhatsApp message, or asking a mutual friend to tell her how much it hurt. In the end, I did nothing. She has a very large following, and some very prominent Jewish people helped her build it. She used that platform to mock Jewish people like me.
Then I heard Bowen Yang say it. On his podcast, Las Culturistas, a guest described the Jewish singer Regina Spektor as “a little Israel hardcore.” Yang replied, “Yeah, she’s Zio.” There was laughter. When the clip resurfaced, Yang apologized, saying he hadn’t known the word’s antisemitic history. In a separate Instagram story, he added, “At the same time, Free Palestine.”
“Zio” is derived from “Zionist.” David Duke, the former Ku Klux Klan grand wizard, helped popularize it as a stand-in for Jews. His website’s “Zio-Watch” section collected stories about Jews and from Jewish publications.
I thought about the horseshoe theory, the idea that the far ends of the political spectrum can bend toward each other. I can imagine my friend recoiling at the mention of David Duke. Yet there was a word he used for Jews, right there on a photo celebrating a Muslim political milestone and taking a swipe at MAGA.
Yang may never have heard that Duke used it. He knew enough to use it as an insult. The guest had already made clear what she thought of Spektor’s support for Israel. Yang supplied the word that got the cheap laugh.
I keep coming back to at the same time. Yang had just apologized for using a slur against a Jewish woman. Why did he feel the need to reaffirm his support for Palestinians in the very next Story? Why did the apology need a political qualification? I wanted the conversations I’d spent years having to make room for exactly this kind of complexity. We could hear about Palestinian grief and Jewish grief in the same conversation. We could disagree about Israel and still be curious about why the person across from us felt the way they did. It takes more of you to ask another question when you’re uncomfortable. A cheap laugh ends the conversation just as surely as walking away does.
I get angry when I hear the word “Zio.” She meant it as a hateful slur, but it’s not the insult she thinks it is. Anyone who knows me knows I’m a proud Zionist. My daughters live in Israel, and I believe in the Jewish people’s right to determine our own future in our ancestral homeland. At a time of heightened antisemitism, using that slur in front of a large audience puts another target on Jewish backs.
What bothered me was how easily she might dismiss me. If I told her the slur hurt, would she hear me as a friend telling her something painful? Or would speaking up just confirm, in her eyes, that I belonged with the “Zios in the back”? How did I end up worrying about sparing her an uncomfortable moment when she’d been so casual about giving me one?
I’m still angry at her. When she reached out after October 7, I was glad to hear from her. I responded without thinking twice. Three years later, I sat looking at that photo, weighing every word of a message I never sent. I wonder if she gave me a second thought before she hit post.
