Ali Vahdati Daneshmand, Bernard Stiegler and the Crisis of Modernity XI
Professor Ali Vahdati Daneshmand is among the Iranian philosophers engaging with Bernard Stiegler’s work. In a 2026 article co-authored with Mohammad Amiri, The Inherent Ambivalence of the Entanglement Between Education and Technology: A Pharmakon-Based Framework in Bernard Stiegler’s Philosophy, he examines technology’s capacity to foster grammatization (دستورسازی, dastur-sāzi), individuation (فردیتیابی, fardiyat-yābi), and sublimation while also producing proletarianization (پرولتاریاییسازی, proletāriyāyi-sāzi). His approach offers a framework for examining how technology reshapes education, memory, and collective life.
Iranian debates about modernity often opposed Westernization to cultural authenticity. Ahmad Fardid’s notion of Gharbzadegi, or “Westoxification,” (and later on Jalal Al-e-Ahmad) expressed concern about cultural dependency and the uncritical adoption of Western models. Heidegger’s critique of modern technology offered another way to question technological rationality. Stiegler proposes a different path. Technology is neither merely an external instrument nor an inevitable source of progress. It participates in the formation of human capacities. The task is therefore not to reject technology but to understand and transform its effects.
The Pharmakon: Technology as Poison and Remedy
At the centre of Stiegler’s philosophy lies the Greek concept of pharmakon, meaning both poison and remedy. Drawing on a concept famously explored by Jacques Derrida, Stiegler uses it to describe the ambivalence of technical systems. Technology can support memory while encouraging dependence, expand communication while fragmenting attention, and democratize access to information while concentrating control over its circulation.
In Iran, the Persian expression dāru va zahr (دارو و زهر)—medicine and poison—offers an accessible way to articulate this tension. Digital networks become zahr when they intensify surveillance, polarization, and distraction.
Yet they can also function as dāru when they facilitate learning, preserve cultural knowledge, and enable intellectual cooperation. In Arabic, the corresponding pair would be samm (سمّ), poison, and dawāʾ (دواء), remedy.
The notion has a longer genealogy than Stiegler. Derrida had already read the pharmakon as what comes from outside and forces the living to relate to its other, at the risk of autoimmunity. Remedy and poison, inside and outside, it has no stable essence: it is the impure medium in which différance is produced. Western tradition tries to purge it through the scapegoat (pharmakos), yet it persists as a supplement. A work, too, is a pharmakon: an orphan, with no father to answer for it, whose teleiopoetic, messianic address reaches an unknown addressee, open to the other without guarantee, both promise and threat.
The ambivalence has a darker counterpart. Heidegger’s Machenschaft and Gestell name the drive to master beings entirely, and the Black Notebooks associate that drive with Jewry, making the Jews, in effect, a pharmakos expelled to purify the West of a crisis of its own making.
Is the pharmakon then the essence of technology? For Derrida, no: in “Plato’s Pharmacy” it is a gesture of reading, a logic of différance, not a definition of technology, and a “new essence” would reinstate the eidos he deconstructs. For Stiegler, in a sense, yes, but never an essence in the metaphysical sense. He generalizes the pharmakon to all technics: every exteriorization of memory (tertiary retention) is at once a condition of individuation and a risk of proletarianization. Hence his “general pharmacology”, a late reformulation of the “originarity of the prosthesis”. He thereby retranslates Heidegger’s “where danger grows, the saving power grows too”: the danger is no longer a destiny of Being but the double face of every pharmakon, and care becomes a political task. Technics thus has no stable nature and is ambivalent from the outset. It is this lack of essence that Stiegler turns into a program, one that Vahdati Daneshmand and Amiri carry into education and technology.
(Editor’s note: Arabic conceptual vocabulary offers another way to explore this ambivalence through related notions: ʿaqqār (عقّار), a medicinal substance or drug; dawāʾ (دواء), a medicine or remedy; mudāwāt (مداواة) and muʿālaja (معالجة), denoting treatment or therapeutic intervention. These terms provide a conceptual vocabulary for distinguishing between a substance and its potential therapeutic use, while the last two invite comparison with the Greek therapeia, understood as care or medical treatment. Persian adds a darker register: dasīse (دسیسه) and towṭeʾe (توطئه) denote machination or plot, echoing the intrigue-laden connotation of Machenschaft, while afsūn (افسون), spell or incantation, recalls the Greek pharmakeia, the sorcerer’s art, and the sense of charm that Derrida finds in the pharmakon.)
Negentropy: Orienting Technology Towards Life
This distinction leads to a further question: what should count as a successful remedy? Stiegler’s concept of negentropy provides a philosophical horizon.
Negentropy should not be understood simply as the restoration of order, opposed to entropy, understood here as disorder (fawḍā (فوضى), chaos in Arabic, and bī-nazmī (بینظمی), lack of order in Persian; order itself being niẓām (نظام) in Arabic and nazm (نظم) in Persian). In Stiegler’s thought, it concerns the production of difference, knowledge, and new possibilities of individuation. Technical supports such as writing, libraries, and digital networks preserve experience across generations and allow knowledge to be transformed. But they can also undermine these processes when they standardize behaviour or concentrate control over knowledge.
A negentropic approach asks whether technologies strengthen people’s ability to learn, interpret, create, and cooperate. Do they cultivate independent judgment, or encourage passive consumption? Do they support diverse forms of knowledge, or impose increasingly uniform patterns of attention?
Within the Arabic vocabulary proposed here, dawāʾ can name the remedial potential of technology when directed towards such outcomes. It is neither a synonym for negentropy nor a guarantee of healing. Rather, it expresses the possibility of orienting technical power towards the renewal of knowledge, attention, and collective agency. The related terms mudāwāt (مداواة) and muʿālaja (معالجة) name the treatment this possibility requires; therapeia, understood as a practice of care, describes this ongoing work. It requires more than individual self-discipline: it also demands responsible technological design, educational reform, and institutions that support independent thought.
The Destruction of Attention and the Proletarianization of the Mind
One central battleground is attention. The Persian expression Eghtesād-e Siyāsi-ye Tavajjoh (اقتصاد سیاسی توجه), or “political economy of attention,” captures the struggle over what people can notice, value, and understand. Tavajjoh means attention and can also carry connotations of consideration or regard.
Digital platforms compete to capture users’ time through notifications, recommendation systems, and rapid content cycles. Although these mechanisms facilitate access to information, they can fragment attention and reward immediate reaction over sustained reflection.
Stiegler describes a related process as proletarianization: the loss not only of control over labour, but also of practical and intellectual capacities. People may lose the know-how to make things, the know-how to live with others, and the know-how to think when these activities are increasingly delegated to automated systems.
Education is particularly vulnerable. Digital tools can broaden access to resources, but digitization may also reduce teachers to executing standardized protocols and students to navigating interfaces. A negentropic approach would instead use technology to deepen understanding, cultivate judgment, and support the production of shared knowledge.
A Bridge Between Iranian Intellectual Traditions and Modern Technology
Stiegler’s ideas can enter into dialogue with Iran’s philosophical and spiritual traditions without being reduced to them. The Persian expression Falsafe-ye Mote’āli-ye Teknoloži (فلسفه متعالی تکنولوژی), or “transcendental philosophy of technology,” may evoke Mulla Sadra’s Hikmat Muta’aliyah. The resemblance offers a point of dialogue, not a claim that the two concepts are identical.
Stiegler’s account of technical memory is especially relevant. Human beings externalize experience through writing, images, archives, and digital networks. These technical supports preserve knowledge beyond individual lifetimes, allowing later generations to reinterpret and transform it. Yet storing information does not automatically produce understanding: people must retain the ability to question and interpret what they inherit.
The Persian term morāghebat (مراقبت), resonant with the Arabic murāqaba (مراقبة), evokes vigilance and watchfulness. In a contemporary technological context, it can suggest the need for collective vigilance over systems that shape public attention and knowledge. Such vigilance must extend beyond personal restraint to public debate, educational institutions, and meaningful participation in technological governance.
Stiegler’s idea of a contributory economy offers a practical direction. Rather than treating people primarily as consumers whose attention is monetized, it seeks to support their participation in producing and sharing knowledge. Digital tools could then strengthen collective intelligence instead of deepening dependency.
From Poison to Care
Stiegler’s philosophy provides a way to think beyond both technological pessimism and uncritical enthusiasm. The pharmakon names technology’s ambivalence: it can weaken attention and autonomy, yet also support memory, learning, and collective creation.
The Persian dāru va zahr expresses this tension, while the Arabic vocabulary proposed here distinguishes three moments: aqqār, the substance “; dawāʾ, its remedial potential; and mudāwāt or muʿālaja, the practice of treatment, which answers to the Greek therapeia, understood as care. Negentropy provides the broader horizon: sustaining knowledge, differentiation, individuation, and the capacity to create new possibilities.
These concepts do not establish a ready-made equivalence across Greek, Persian, Arabic, and French traditions. Instead, they open a shared inquiry into how technology might serve life rather than merely capture attention.
In Iran, this inquiry speaks to the tensions between institutional authority, cultural continuity, and a digitally connected generation seeking room to think and act. Globally, it raises the same fundamental challenge: how can societies transform technological power into a resource for collective intelligence?
The remedy is neither a particular device nor a single policy. It is an ongoing social and political practice: organizing technology so that it supports care, autonomy, and the renewal of knowledge. The poison cannot simply be removed from the pharmakon. The task is to cultivate the collective capacities through which its power can be redirected towards life.

