‘Marginal’ Lithuanian Citizenship
In a country this small, the rule against Jews never needed to be written down. It only needed the same people.
I live in Los Angeles. The five counties of Greater Los Angeles hold more than 18 million people. Lithuania’s 2021 census counted 2,810,761 residents. The whole country would fit into my region six times over. By the standards of the city I live in, Lithuania is a neighborhood. A marginal one.
It is also a neighborhood without its Jews. Before the war, more than 200,000 Jews lived in what is now Lithuania. Almost all of them were murdered, with Lithuanian police, battalions and local men doing much of the murdering. Today Statistics Lithuania describes the country, in its own words, as “a homogeneous state in terms of ethnic composition.” In its 2021 census, Lithuanians made up 84.6 percent.
In a neighborhood, people know one another. They share a purpose. Rules do not always need to be written, because everyone already knows how things are done. That is how I have come to understand Lithuania’s treatment of Jews who ask for their grandparents’ citizenship and property. The written law changes. The handling does not. The full documentary record, with every source, is in “Marginal” Lithuanian Citizenship. This is the short version, told through the people who keep appearing in it.
The father and the son
In the summer of 1941 the Provisional Government formed after the Lithuanian Activist Front’s uprising declared that nationalized Jewish property “remains the property of the Lithuanian state.” Its law denationalizing urban houses provided that the houses of Jews “are not to be returned” to their owners. That law was signed by the acting Prime Minister and by Vytautas Landsbergis-Žemkalnis, Minister of Communal Economy. That same summer, across Lithuania, the Jewish owners were being slaughtered en masse.
Fifty years later the restored republic enacted its own restitution law. Law No. I-1454 of 1991 restored property only to citizens living in Lithuania. Most Jewish owners had been murdered; most surviving heirs lived abroad. That December, a Citizenship Law denied citizenship rights to prewar citizens who had “repatriated,” which the Constitutional Court later found meant departure to one’s ethnic homeland. To illustrate: two citizens of prewar Lithuania leave the same country. One is a Lithuanian who moves to Chicago. The other is a Jew who moves to Tel Aviv. The Lithuanian keeps his right to Lithuanian citizenship, because Chicago is not his ethnic homeland. The Jew loses his, because the law decides that Lithuania was never his homeland and Israel always was. Same country of birth. Same citizenship. Same act of leaving. The law assigned the Jew a different homeland, and it did so because he was a Jew.
Both 1991 laws were signed by the President of the Supreme Council, Professor Vytautas Landsbergis, the son of the 1941 minister. I documented the signatures in The Professor Asked Who Signed. He Did Too. I do not claim to know what the son intended. I know what the laws did. The murdered could not apply. Most of their heirs, scattered across the world by emigration and the murders, could not pass the citizenship gate, and those who had gone to Israel were excluded as having gone “home.” Property Lithuania’s 1941 government had declared its own stayed, for most Jewish families, in Lithuanian hands. The theft of 1941 was not undone in 1991. For most Jewish heirs, it was confirmed. The filing deadline passed on December 31, 2001. The Constitutional Court struck down the repatriation rule in November 2006, under the constitutional article that forbids restricting rights on the ground of race, nationality or origin. The deadline was never reopened.
Consider what “repatriated” did. Jewish tradition dates Jewish life in Lithuania to Grand Duke Gediminas in the 1320s, nearly seven centuries. The earliest surviving charters, from Vytautas the Great, date to 1388. Jews built Vilna into the Jerusalem of Lithuania. They held Lithuanian passports. They served in its army; my grandfather wore its uniform. Lithuanians helped murder them. Then, in 1991, the restored republic told those who had survived and escaped, and those who had left before the war, that their homeland was Israel, because they were Jews. That is what Lietuva-Lietuviams, “Lithuania for Lithuanians,” means. It means exclusion. It means that a Jew, however many generations his family lived there, is never of Lithuania, only in it, and is expected to leave. To me, the 1991 rule gave that slogan legal effect, half a century after the slogan had been carried out with rifles. I call it what it is: a racist rule, written by a state that had just finished asking the world to recognize its own right to a homeland.
The official in the courtroom, and in my file
When the Constitutional Court heard the repatriation case in October 2006, one specialist from the Migration Department took the floor: D. Vežikauskaitė, Head of its Citizenship Section. The Court then struck down the rule that had excluded Jews who went to Israel.
Seven years later, on October 31, 2013, a letter from the Department’s Citizenship Division confirmed that my grandfather had been a Lithuanian citizen. It then halted my application and my twelve-year-old son’s until I explained why my grandfather had left Lithuania. It also asked whether we held Israeli citizenship. It cited no provision for that question. The letter was signed by the head of the division: Daiva Vežikauskaitė. The official who had addressed the Court in the repatriation case signed the letter asking whether my son and I held Israeli citizenship. The Department must explain the question’s legal basis and relevance.
The consul
The law offered restoration of citizenship to the descendants of prewar citizens. When I applied in 2004, the form required my “nationality.” I asked Lithuania’s long-serving Honorary Consul General in Los Angeles, Vytautas Čekanauskas, what to write. As I recorded in my 2013 book, Malice, Murder and Manipulation, he told me I was required to write “Jew” as my nationality. He explained that a Jew was a Jew, a Lithuanian was a Lithuanian, a Jew could not be Lithuanian, and a Lithuanian could not be a Jew. He added that if I wrote anything else, the application would be treated as fraudulent and denied.
No statute says a Jew cannot be Lithuanian. None was needed. The state’s representative said it to my face, and the form recorded the answer. That was Lietuva-Lietuviams, Lithuania for Lithuanians, applied across a consulate desk in Los Angeles.
The Department and the burned records
The Migration Department then spent two and a half years demanding my grandfather’s birth record from the Papilė registers that burned in 1915. In 1922 the same demand had kept my great-grandfather’s family out of Lithuania; my great-grandfather had already died of starvation in exile. More than eighty years later the demand returned from a different office. The Department told a court that two Samuel Gochins might have been born in Papilė around 1902. It never produced a second one. Then, when I appealed to the Supreme Administrative Court, the Department answered in writing that I was misleading the court. According to the English translation of the Court’s decision, it said I “deceitfully” claimed that the 1926 passport ledger recorded a Samuel Gochin born in Papilė. Separately, it argued that I had no basis to say the Papilė registers were destroyed, because they might be held in “other archives, museums or elsewhere.” Lithuania’s own historical archive had already certified that it did not hold them. The state that demanded records it could not find accused the Jewish applicant of deceit about his grandfather’s birthplace. It did so in a court of law. The Supreme Administrative Court found its reasoning inadequate in 2011. My citizenship was restored in 2014, twenty-five years after I first approached Lithuania.
The rule that was repealed and came back
This is where the unwritten system shows itself. By 2015 the Department was refusing Litvak applicants who could not prove their ancestors had fled persecution. The Lithuanian Jewish Community counted 10 refusals in 2014, 76 in 2015 and 97 in the first quarter of 2016. In June 2016 the Seimas changed the law, replacing “fled” with “left.” The Jewish world was told Lithuania had lifted a major obstruction.
No law put the obstruction back. On March 18, 2026, the Supreme Administrative Court ruled against a family whose ancestor left for South Africa in 1921. From three dates, his arrival in 1921, his daughter’s birth in 1938 and his death in 1940, it inferred that he had not left for political reasons. No party had argued the point, and the family told the Court it never had the chance to address it.
Then the Ministry of the Interior, which had won, asked the Court to reopen its own victory. The Ministry told the Court that “left” means a change of residence and nothing more. On November 4 the Court refused. In the same order it wrote that departure from Lithuania “need not be forced,” that its March ruling did not change the direction of its case law, and that its discussion of departure reasons had not been essential to the outcome. It also told state institutions to follow its 2017 ruling, which speaks of citizens who “were forced to leave Lithuania.” Meanwhile, the applicants told the Court, the Migration Department was suspending files and sending families notices demanding to know why their ancestors left.
The Ministry argued that the test is not in the law. The Court says leaving need not be forced, and in the same order points institutions to a ruling about forced departure. The Department, on the applicants’ evidence, asks for the reasons anyway. A written rule would have to choose one of those positions. An unwritten one can hold all three. Nobody in Vilnius has to write down how a Jew’s application is handled. The officials know. They knew in 1922, when the Department of Citizens’ Security demanded burned records. They knew in 2004, when the consul told me what to write. They knew in 2013, when the Migration Department asked about Israel. They knew in 2026, when the notices went out. The law is rewritten. The handling is not.
The judges
Consider who sat on these cases. In July 2011, a three-judge panel of the Supreme Administrative Court that included Skirgailė Žalimienė and Audrius Bakaveckas ruled for me. It held that Lithuanian law sets no closed list of documents a family must produce, and that the Department had to weigh all of a family’s evidence together: the army records, the passport ledger, the birth certificates, the testimony of relatives. On that basis it overturned the Department.
Fifteen years later, Žalimienė chaired the March 2026 panel that inferred an ancestor’s motive from three dates without weighing any family evidence on the point. In November, Bakaveckas chaired the panel that refused the Ministry’s own request to reopen that judgment.
The legal questions were different, but the contrast in reasoning is plain: in 2011 the Court required all of a family’s evidence to be weighed together; in 2026 it relied on three dates, and declined to revisit them even when the winning Ministry asked. Two of the judges were on both sides of that change. In a small country, the same few people decide who belongs.
The historian
The Genocide and Resistance Research Centre of Lithuania published, in its 2020 English volume, Darius Furmonavičius’s conclusion that Lithuanian participation in the murder of Lithuania’s Jews was “essentially marginal.” On November 3, 2026, acting Director General Arūnas Bubnys signed the Centre’s refusal to correct it. In October he had signed another letter telling me that the Activist Front’s documents, including its promise that in the restored Lithuania no Jew would have “the rights of citizenship,” have no legal force. In 2000, in a note to the Seimas, the same Centre had acknowledged anti-Jewish provisions in the Provisional Government’s property decrees. It did not mention that note to me.
The series so far
This is one installment of a series that tests the word “marginal” against Lithuania’s own records. Each installment takes one subject:
- “Marginal” Murders
- “Marginal” Rapes
- “Marginal” Infanticide
- “Marginal” Plunder
- “Marginal” Slavery
- “Marginal” Sacrilege
- “Marginal” Arithmetic
- “Marginal” Auctions
- “Marginal” Heroes
- “Marginal” Signatures
- “Marginal” Research
- “Marginal” Laws
- “Marginal” Lithuanian Citizenship, the full record behind this article
The committee
In October 2026 I asked the Seimas Committee on Legal Affairs what remedy exists for heirs excluded by an unconstitutional rule after a deadline that closed before the judgment. The Committee listed legislation and constitutional order among its fields. Then it declined the question as history, and named no one who would answer it.
What I am, and am not, claiming
I do not claim a meeting, a memo or a plot. I have not seen an internal instruction directing officials to preserve the departure-reasons requirement after the 2016 amendment. The repeated demands make disclosure of their instructions necessary. I claim a result that keeps arriving without one. In 1922, 1941, 1991, 2004, 2013 and 2026, different offices under different laws repeatedly placed additional barriers between Jewish families and recognition. When a rule was struck down, the questions continued. When a law was changed to help us, the obstruction returned through reasoning about departure motives that no party had advanced.
In a region of 18 million, you might call that coincidence. In a country of 2.8 million, where the same names recur from one decade to the next, it is a culture of administration. The records establish repeated barriers and institutions that have not reconciled their positions. Lithuania must disclose who instructed its officials, what they were told to demand, and why families kept encountering conditions the public had been told were removed.
Lithuania has one asset left for us: its citizenship. It is our heritage right. I urge every Litvak to reclaim it, with pride, as a statement that we are still here, that they did not murder all of us, and that we are not going away.
If your family is applying and the Migration Department asks why your ancestors left, start with the town. The Lithuania Project town research reports cover hundreds of towns, villages and killing sites. They are free. They draw on archival documents, investigation files, court judgments, memorial books and survivor testimony, and where the evidence allows they record what Jews faced before the Holocaust: the Tsar’s deportations of 1915, the refusals to let families return, the expulsions of the 1920s, boycotts and violence. Find your ancestor’s town, read what happened there in the years before your family left, and take those sources to your lawyer. A family statement is stronger when it rests on dated documents from the town your family came from.
Lithuania’s Genocide Centre still tells the world that Lithuanian participation in the murder of some 200,000 Jews, and in the annihilation of a civilization that had stood on its soil for centuries, was “essentially marginal.” It was marginal in exactly the way Lithuania’s citizenship law is marginal to Jews: written one way, applied another. In my family’s case, recognition came only after years of demands and litigation. Lithuania knows what it did; its own archives record it. I call “essentially marginal” a lie. The Centre was shown the record and refused to correct the word. Acting Director General Arūnas Bubnys signed that refusal.

